晚期CKD患者肾衰竭预测模型的外部验证研究
该研究在EQUAL和SRR两个大型队列中外部验证了11个肾衰竭预测模型,并考虑死亡竞争风险。结果显示2年KFRE和4年Grams模型校准良好、判别力好,而5年KFRE高估风险10%-18%。
要点
- 2年KFRE(四变量和八变量)在晚期CKD患者中校准优异且判别力好。
- 4年Grams模型因考虑竞争风险,适合长期预测且表现良好。
- 5年KFRE高估肾衰竭风险10%-18%,因未充分处理死亡竞争风险。
核心结论
- 部分现有模型可准确预测晚期CKD患者的肾衰竭,短时间框架(2年)KFRE表现良好,长时间框架(5年)模型因竞争风险高估风险,Grams模型适合4年预测。
研究设计与样本
- 外部验证11个肾衰竭预测模型,纳入EQUAL前瞻性多中心队列的1580例老年晚期CKD患者和瑞典肾脏登记(SRR)的13489例肾内科转诊CKD患者,考虑死亡竞争风险。
主要发现
- 11个验证模型平均c统计量在EQUAL为0.74、SRR为0.80,此前验证为0.89。
- 多数较长预测时间范围的模型显著高估肾衰竭风险。
- 5年KFRE高估风险10%-18%。
- 四变量和八变量2年KFRE及4年Grams模型在两个队列中校准优异且判别力好。
关键数值与推荐
- 肾衰竭定义为需要肾脏替代治疗的终末期肾病(RRT-treated ESKD)。
- 模型性能用判别力(c统计量)和校准评估。
- 5年KFRE高估风险10%-18%。
临床怎么用
- 晚期CKD患者短期(2年)肾衰竭风险预测可选用KFRE(四变量或八变量)。
- 长期(4年)预测可选用考虑竞争风险的Grams模型。
- 使用5年KFRE时需注意其可能高估风险。
局限性
- 未纳入指南推荐模型的头对头比较。
- 缺乏在晚期CKD患者中的验证。
- 多数模型未考虑竞争风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Various prediction models have been developed to predict the risk of kidney failure in patients with CKD. However, guideline-recommended models have yet to be compared head to head, their validation in patients with advanced CKD is lacking, and most do not account for competing risks. METHODS: To externally validate 11 existing models of kidney failure, taking the competing risk of death into account, we included patients with advanced CKD from two large cohorts: the European Quality Study (EQUAL), an ongoing European prospective, multicenter cohort study of older patients with advanced CKD, and the Swedish Renal Registry (SRR), an ongoing registry of nephrology-referred patients with CKD in Sweden. The outcome of the models was kidney failure (defined as RRT-treated ESKD). We assessed model performance with discrimination and calibration. RESULTS: The study included 1580 patients from EQUAL and 13,489 patients from SRR. The average c statistic over the 11 validated models was 0.74 in EQUAL and 0.80 in SRR, compared with 0.89 in previous validations. Most models with longer prediction horizons overestimated the risk of kidney failure considerably. The 5-year Kidney Failure Risk Equation (KFRE) overpredicted risk by 10%-18%. The four- and eight-variable 2-year KFRE and the 4-year Grams model showed excellent calibration and good discrimination in both cohorts. CONCLUSIONS: Some existing models can accurately predict kidney failure in patients with advanced CKD. KFRE performed well for a shorter time frame (2 years), despite not accounting for competing events. Models predicting over a longer time frame (5 years) overestimated risk because of the competing risk of death. The Grams model, which accounts for the latter, is suitable for longer-term predictions (4 years).
引用
- Ramspek CL, Evans M, Wanner C, et al. Kidney Failure Prediction Models: A Comprehensive External Validation Study in Patients with Advanced CKD. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2021. PMID: 33685974. doi:10.1681/ASN.2020071077
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。