肾内科专科培训医师沟通技能评估:多中心临床模拟研究
该多中心观察性研究通过「坏消息告知」模拟场景,评估了58名肾内科专科培训医师在肾脏替代治疗(KRT)和肾活检沟通中的表现。结果显示,不同培训年限医师的沟通综合评分无显著差异(P=0.2),但在急性肾损伤(AKI)和肾活检场景中,分别有37%和53%的医师至少一项Mini-CEX评分低于3分。结构化模拟临床考试可能有助于课程设置和沟通能力评估。
要点
- 肾内科专科培训医师的沟通能力在培训早期即已达到较高水平,与培训年限无关。
- 医师在肾衰竭场景中的沟通表现优于AKI和肾活检场景。
- 结构化模拟临床考试可作为沟通和专业素养的有效评估工具。
核心结论
- 肾内科专科培训医师在EEC-GRS总体评分上得分较高,且与培训年限无关,提示人际沟通能力在培训早期即已具备。
- 医师在肾衰竭场景中的表现优于AKI和肾活检场景。
- 结构化模拟临床考试可能有助于指导课程设置,并可作为沟通和专业素养的评估工具。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心观察性研究,评估肾内科专科培训医师的沟通能力。
- 共纳入58名一年级和二年级肾内科专科培训医师,在2017年和2018年于8个培训项目中进行71次临床评估会话。
主要发现
- EEC-GRS总体评分项的综合得分在不同培训年限间无显著差异(P=0.2)。
- 在71次评估中,仅4次在任一场景的EEC-GRS总体评分项上得分不满意。
- 在肾衰竭场景中,17%的医师至少一项Mini-CEX评分低于3分;在AKI和肾活检场景中,分别有37%和53%的医师至少一项Mini-CEX评分低于3分。
- 调查显示,96%的医师和100%的教师认为学习目标已达成,并在3个调查评分问题上将体验评为良好或更好。
临床怎么用
- 结构化模拟临床考试可用于评估肾内科专科培训医师的沟通技能,并指导课程设置。
- 针对AKI和肾活检场景的沟通培训可能需要加强。
局限性
- 互动时间相对较短。
- 模拟患者对EEC-GRS的熟悉程度和培训有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Interpersonal communication skills and professionalism competencies are difficult to assess among nephrology trainees. We developed a formative "Breaking Bad News" simulation and implemented a study in which nephrology fellows were assessed with regard to their skills in providing counseling to simulated patients confronting the need for kidney replacement therapy (KRT) or kidney biopsy. STUDY DESIGN: Observational study of communication competency in the setting of preparing for KRT for kidney failure, for KRT for acute kidney injury (AKI), or for kidney biopsy. SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: 58 first- and second-year nephrology fellows assessed during 71 clinical evaluation sessions at 8 training programs who participated in an objective structured clinical examination of simulated patients in 2017 and 2018. PREDICTORS: Fellowship training year and clinical scenario. OUTCOME: Primary outcome was the composite score for the "overall rating" item on the Essential Elements of Communication-Global Rating Scale 2005 (EEC-GRS), as assessed by simulated patients. Secondary outcomes were the score for EEC-GRS "overall rating" item for each scenario, score < 3 for any EEC-GRS item, Mini-Clinical Examination Exercise (Mini-CEX) score < 3 on at least 1 item (as assessed by faculty), and faculty and fellow satisfaction with simulation exercise (via a survey they completed). ANALYTICAL APPROACH: Nonparametric tests of hypothesis comparing performance by fellowship year (primary goal) and scenario. RESULTS: Composite scores for EEC-GRS overall rating item were not significantly different between fellowship years (P = 0.2). Only 4 of 71 fellow evaluations had an unsatisfactory score for the EEC-GRS overall rating item on any scenario. On Mini-CEX, 17% scored < 3 on at least 1 item in the kidney failure scenario; 37% and 53% scored < 3 on at least 1 item in the AKI and kidney biopsy scenarios, respectively. In the survey, 96% of fellows and 100% of faculty reported the learning objectives were met and rated the experience good or better in 3 survey rating questions. LIMITATIONS: Relatively brief time for interactions; limited familiarity with and training of simulated patients in use of EEC-GRS. CONCLUSIONS: The fellows scored highly on the EEC-GRS regardless of their training year, suggesting interpersonal communication competency is achieved early in training. The fellows did better with the kidney failure scenario than with the AKI and kidney biopsy scenarios. Structured simulated clinical examinations may be useful to inform curricular choices and may be a valuable assessment tool for communication and professionalism.
引用
- Prince LK, Howle AM, Mikita J, et al. Assessing Nephrology Fellows' Skills in Communicating About Kidney Replacement Therapy and Kidney Biopsy: A Multicenter Clinical Simulation Study on Breaking Bad News. Am J Kidney Dis. 2021. PMID: 33741490. doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2021.02.323
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。