新型体力活动问卷评估慢性肾脏病患者能量消耗
本研究分三阶段开发并验证用于慢性肾脏病(CKD)的体力活动问卷CKD-PAQ:第一阶段基于RPAQ开发原型并获40例患者反馈;第二阶段在226例患者中经3轮迭代对照7天加速度计和RPAQ优化;第三阶段在523例患者中与RPAQ比较。结果显示CKD-PAQ与加速度计在MET和TEE上一致性尚可至良好,与RPAQ一致性良好至优秀,且问卷更简短、更易完成,可能更好捕捉低水平活动。
要点
- CKD-PAQ与加速度计在MET上一致性尚可、TEE上良好。
- CKD-PAQ与RPAQ一致性良好(MET)至优秀(TEE)。
- CKD-PAQ更简短易完成,可能更好区分低活动组。
核心结论
- CKD-PAQ表现与RPAQ相当,但更简短易完成,可能更好捕捉低水平活动并改善低活动组区分。
研究设计与样本
- 三阶段研究:第一阶段基于RPAQ开发原型并获40例CKD患者结构化反馈;第二阶段在226例CKD患者中经3轮迭代对照7天加速度计和RPAQ优化;第三阶段在523例CKD患者中比较最终版CKD-PAQ与RPAQ。
主要发现
- 第二阶段最终迭代60例患者中,CKD-PAQ与加速度计MET一致性尚可(ICC fair)、TEE一致性良好(ICC good),CKD-PAQ与RPAQ一致性优秀。
- CKD-PAQ的日均MET偏差(SD)为0.035(0.312),RPAQ为0.018(0.326);TEE偏差(SD)CKD-PAQ为91(518)kcal,RPAQ为44(548)kcal。
- 两参数的一致性限(LOA)均较宽,但CKD-PAQ值离散度更小。
- 第三阶段CKD-PAQ与RPAQ一致性MET良好、TEE优秀;CKD-PAQ较RPAQ的日均MET偏差(SD)为0.031(0.193),95% LOA -0.346至0.409;TEE偏差(SD)为48(325)kcal/day,95% LOA -588至685 kcal/day。
- CKD-PAQ似乎改善了低活动组间的区分。
临床怎么用
- CKD-PAQ可用于CKD患者体力活动评估,尤其适合需简短工具的场景。
- 解读CKD-PAQ结果时需注意MET和TEE的LOA较宽,个体层面偏差可能较大。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Physical activity (PA) levels are low in patients with advanced chronic kidney disease (CKD), and associate with increased morbidity and mortality. Reliable tools to assess PA in CKD are scarce. We aimed to develop and validate a novel PA questionnaire for use in CKD (CKD-PAQ). METHODS: In Phase 1, a prototype questionnaire was developed based on the validated recent PAQ (RPAQ). Structured feedback on item relevance and clarity was obtained from 40 CKD patients. In Phase 2, the questionnaire was refined in three iterations in a total of 226 CKD patients against 7-day accelerometer and RPAQ measurements. In Phase 3, the definitive CKD-PAQ was compared with RPAQ in 523 CKD patients. RESULTS: In the final iteration of Phase 2, CKD-PAQ data were compared with accelerometer-derived and RPAQ data in 60 patients. Mean daily metabolic equivalent of task (MET) and total energy expenditure (TEE) levels were similar by all methods. Intraclass correlation coefficients showed fair (MET) and good (TEE) agreement between accelerometry and both CKD-PAQ and RPAQ. Agreement between questionnaires was excellent. The mean [standard deviation (SD)] daily MET bias was 0.035 (0.312) for CKD-PAQ and 0.018 (0.326) for RPAQ. The mean (SD) TEE bias was 91 (518) for CKD-PAQ and 44 (548) kcal for RPAQ. Limits of agreement (LOA) were wide for both parameters, with less dispersion of CKD-PAQ values. In Phase 3, agreement between questionnaires was good (MET) and excellent (TEE). Bias of CKD-PAQ-derived mean (SD) daily MET from RPAQ-derived values was 0.031 (0.193), with 95% LOA -0.346 to 0.409. Corresponding mean (SD) values for TEE were 48 (325) and -588 to 685 kcal/day. CKD-PAQ appeared to improve discrimination between low activity groups. CONCLUSIONS: CKD-PAQ performs comparably to the RPAQ though it is shorter, easier to complete, and may better capture low-level activity and improve discrimination between low activity groups.
引用
- Sridharan S, Vilar E, Ramanarayanan S, et al. Energy expenditure estimates in chronic kidney disease using a novel physical activity questionnaire. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2022. PMID: 33416874. doi:10.1093/ndt/gfaa377
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。