学术型重症监护室中的肾脏病学:跨学科协作的定性研究
该研究采用聚焦民族志方法,通过150小时参与观察和35次半结构化访谈,探讨学术医学中心3个ICU中肾脏病顾问与ICU团队的互动。发现肾脏病顾问与外科ICU团队在肾脏替代治疗 aggressiveness 上存在偏好分歧,源于对生理学、照护目标和病情急迫性的理解不同,导致顾问常充当日透析操作者而非诊断者,且有时因认为不会改变治疗进程而不表达临床分歧。
要点
- 肾脏病顾问与外科ICU团队对RRT aggressiveness偏好不一致
- 分歧使顾问在外科ICU多承担透析操作而非诊断角色
- 顾问因认为不会改变治疗而不表达临床分歧
核心结论
- 内科培训的肾脏病医生与麻醉/外科培训的重症医生及外科医生之间的方法差异导致外科ICU协作困难。
- 研究强调需要医学团队合作研究和干预,以解决源于长期社会化不同学科实践的学科孤岛问题。
研究设计与样本
- 聚焦民族志研究,采用半结构化访谈和参与观察。
- 目的性抽样纳入肾脏病专家、肾脏病研究员和ICU从业者,在3个ICU(内科ICU、外科ICU、心胸外科ICU)进行。
- 参与观察150小时,半结构化访谈35次,持续至理论饱和。
主要发现
- 肾脏病顾问与外科ICU团队对肾脏替代治疗 aggressiveness 的偏好不一致,基于对生理学、照护目标和急迫性的不同理解。
- 协作困难导致肾脏病顾问在外科ICU常充当日透析操作者而非诊断者。
- 顾问有时因相信不会改变治疗进程而选择不表达临床分歧。
临床怎么用
- 肾内科医生应意识到与外科ICU团队在RRT偏好上的潜在分歧,主动沟通以明确角色。
- 在协作中关注学科社会化差异对团队合作的影响,促进跨学科对话。
局限性
- 单中心学术医学中心研究,结果可能不适用于其他临床环境和样本。
- 缺乏外科团队视角,未考察研究发现对患者照护的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Collaboration between nephrology consultants and intensive care unit (ICU) teams is important in light of the high incidence of acute kidney injury in today's ICUs. Although there is considerable debate about how nephrology consultants and ICU teams should collaborate, communicative dynamics between the 2 parties remain poorly understood. This article describes interactions between nephrology consultants and ICU teams in the academic medical setting. STUDY DESIGN: Focused ethnography using semi-structured interviews and participant observation. SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: Purposive sampling was used to enroll nephrologists, nephrology fellows, and ICU practitioners across several roles collaborating in 3 ICUs (a medical ICU, a surgical ICU, and a cardiothoracic surgical ICU) of a large urban US academic medical center. Participant observation (150 hours) and semi-structured interviews (35) continued until theoretical saturation. ANALYTICAL APPROACH: Interview and fieldnote transcripts were coded in an iterative team-based process. Explanation was developed using an abductive approach. RESULTS: Nephrology consultants and surgical ICU teams exhibited discordant preferences about the aggressiveness of renal replacement therapy based on different understandings of physiology, goals of care, and acuity. Collaborative difficulties resulting from this discordance led to nephrology consultants often serving as dialysis proceduralists rather than diagnosticians in surgical ICUs and to consultants sometimes choosing not to express disagreements about clinical care because of the belief that doing so would not lead to changes in the course of care. LIMITATIONS: Aspects of this single-site study of an academic medical center may not be generalizable to other clinical settings and samples. Surgical team perspectives would provide further detail about nephrology consultation in surgical ICUs. The effects of findings on patient care were not examined. CONCLUSIONS: Differences in approach between internal medicine-trained nephrologists and anesthesia- and surgery-trained intensivists and surgeons led to collaborative difficulties in surgical ICUs. These findings stress the need for medical teamwork research and intervention to address issues stemming from disciplinary siloing rooted in long-term socialization to different disciplinary practices.
引用
- Clapp JT, Diraviam SP, Lane-Fall MB, et al. Nephrology in the Academic Intensive Care Unit: A Qualitative Study of Interdisciplinary Collaboration. Am J Kidney Dis. 2019. PMID: 31492489. doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2019.05.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。