家庭血液透析中纽扣孔与阶梯式穿刺的多中心随机先导试验
本研究评估在加拿大7家医院家庭血透培训患者中随机分配纽扣孔与阶梯式动静脉内瘘穿刺技术的可行性。158例开始培训,仅50例符合条件,14例(28%)同意随机。纽扣孔组培训时间较短,但穿刺疼痛或并发症未见减少,研究未能证明足够可行性以得出有意义结论。
要点
- 家庭血透患者随机接受纽扣孔或阶梯式穿刺的招募可行性低,仅28%符合条件者同意。
- 纽扣孔穿刺完成家庭血透培训所需时间较短。
- 纽扣孔穿刺未减少穿刺疼痛或并发症。
核心结论
- 在加拿大无法证明开展纽扣孔与阶梯式穿刺随机对照试验的可行性,因家庭血透患者数量不足以得出有意义结论。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心随机先导试验,评估加拿大7家医院家庭血透培训患者的随机可行性,记录培训时间、穿刺疼痛和12个月内并发症。
主要发现
- 158例开始家庭血透培训,108例不符合条件;不符合者中糖尿病作为ESKD病因(31% vs 12%)和中心静脉导管使用(74% vs 6%)更常见。
- 50例符合条件者中14例(28%)同意随机,最常见拒绝原因是对特定穿刺技术的强烈偏好(33%)。
- 随机至纽扣孔与阶梯式穿刺的患者完成家庭血透培训所需时间较短,但穿刺疼痛或并发症未见减少。
临床怎么用
- 纽扣孔穿刺可能缩短家庭血透培训时间,但未显示减少穿刺疼痛或并发症,临床选择需结合患者偏好。
局限性
- 招募可行性低,样本量小,未进行正式成本分析的数据链接。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Canadian home hemodialysis guidelines highlight the potential differences in complications associated with arteriovenous fistula (AVF) cannulation technique as a research priority. Our primary objective was to determine the feasibility of randomizing patients with ESKD training for home hemodialysis to buttonhole versus stepladder cannulation of the AVF. Secondary objectives included training time, pain with needling, complications, and cost by cannulation technique. DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS: All patients training for home hemodialysis at seven Canadian hospitals were assessed for eligibility, and demographic information and access type was collected on everyone. Patients who consented to participate were randomized to buttonhole or stepladder cannulation technique. Time to train for home hemodialysis, pain scores on cannulation, and complications over 12 months was recorded. For eligible but not randomized patients, reasons for not participating in the trial were documented. RESULTS: Patient recruitment was November 2013 to November 2015. During this time, 158 patients began training for home hemodialysis, and 108 were ineligible for the trial. Diabetes mellitus as a cause of ESKD (31% versus 12%) and central venous catheter use (74% versus 6%) were more common in ineligible patients. Of the 50 eligible patients, 14 patients from four out of seven sites consented to participate in the study (28%). The most common reason for declining to participate was a strong preference for a particular cannulation technique (33%). Patients randomized to buttonhole versus stepladder cannulation required a shorter time to complete home hemodialysis training. We did not observe a reduction in cannulation pain or complications with the buttonhole method. Data linkages for a formal cost analysis were not conducted. CONCLUSIONS: We were unable to demonstrate the feasibility of conducting a randomized, controlled trial of buttonhole versus stepladder cannulation in Canada with a sufficient number of patients on home hemodialysis to be able to draw meaningful conclusions.
引用
- Huang SS, MacRae J, Ross D, et al. Buttonhole versus Stepladder Cannulation for Home Hemodialysis: A Multicenter, Randomized, Pilot Trial. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2019. PMID: 30659057. doi:10.2215/CJN.08310718
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。