活体肾捐献者重视的结局:名义群体技术研究
该研究在澳大利亚和加拿大三个移植中心 purposively 抽样既往活体肾捐献者,采用名义群体技术进行焦点小组讨论,识别并排序捐献者认为重要的结局。123名捐献者共识别35个结局,最重要的包括肾功能、恢复时间、手术并发症、对家庭的影响及供受者关系,且加拿大与澳大利亚捐献者在肾功能和肾衰竭重要性上存在差异。
要点
- 活体肾捐献者最重视肾功能、恢复时间、手术并发症及心理社会影响。
- 捐献者高度重视对家庭生活及供受者关系的改善。
- 肾功能和肾衰竭的重要性在加拿大与澳大利亚捐献者间存在区域差异。
核心结论
- 活体肾捐献者优先考虑肾功能健康及捐献带来的手术、生活方式、功能与心理社会影响。
研究设计与样本
- 在澳大利亚悉尼、墨尔本和加拿大温哥华三个移植中心 purposively 抽样既往活体肾捐献者,开展14个焦点小组,采用名义群体技术识别、排序并讨论捐献结局。
主要发现
- 123名年龄27-78岁的捐献者共识别35个结局,重要性评分最高为肾功能(0.40,量表0-1),其次为恢复时间(0.27)、手术并发症(0.24)、对家庭的影响(0.22)、供受者关系(0.21)。
- 其他高排名结局包括生活满意度(0.18)、生活方式限制(0.18)、肾衰竭(0.14)、死亡(0.13)和急性疼痛/不适(0.12)。
- 加拿大捐献者比澳大利亚捐献者更重视肾功能和肾衰竭。
- 定性主题包括值得的牺牲、风险与伤害的微不足道、信心与赋权、未实现的期望及易感性增高。
关键数值与推荐
- 肾功能重要性评分为0.40(量表0-1),恢复时间0.27,手术并发症0.24,对家庭的影响0.22,供受者关系0.21。
临床怎么用
- 临床知情同意应优先讨论肾功能、恢复时间、手术并发症及心理社会影响等捐献者最重视的结局。
- 应关注捐献者对家庭生活及供受者关系的期望,并提供区域差异化的信息。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入澳大利亚和加拿大三个移植中心的既往捐献者,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Living kidney donor candidates accept a range of risks and benefits when they decide to proceed with nephrectomy. Informed consent around this decision assumes they receive reliable data about outcomes they regard as critical to their decision making. We identified the outcomes most important to living kidney donors and described the reasons for their choices. DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS: Previous donors were purposively sampled from three transplant units in Australia (Sydney and Melbourne) and Canada (Vancouver). In focus groups using the nominal group technique, participants identified outcomes of donation, ranked them in order of importance, and discussed the reasons for their preferences. An importance score was calculated for each outcome. Qualitative data were analyzed thematically. RESULTS: Across 14 groups, 123 donors aged 27-78 years identified 35 outcomes. Across all participants, the ten highest ranked outcomes were kidney function (importance=0.40, scale 0-1), time to recovery (0.27), surgical complications (0.24), effect on family (0.22), donor-recipient relationship (0.21), life satisfaction (0.18), lifestyle restrictions (0.18), kidney failure (0.14), mortality (0.13), and acute pain/discomfort (0.12). Kidney function and kidney failure were more important to Canadian participants, compared with Australian donors. The themes identified included worthwhile sacrifice, insignificance of risks and harms, confidence and empowerment, unfulfilled expectations, and heightened susceptibility. CONCLUSIONS: Living kidney donors prioritized a range of outcomes, with the most important being kidney health and the surgical, lifestyle, functional, and psychosocial effects of donation. Donors also valued improvements to their family life and donor-recipient relationship. There were clear regional differences in the rankings.
引用
- Hanson CS, Chapman JR, Gill JS, et al. Identifying Outcomes that Are Important to Living Kidney Donors: A Nominal Group Technique Study. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2018. PMID: 29853616. doi:10.2215/CJN.13441217
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。