肾内科医生对老年CKD患者讨论保守管理的访谈研究
该研究通过对美国35名肾内科医生的半结构化访谈,探讨了影响医生与老年肾衰竭患者讨论保守管理的因素。研究发现仅37%的医生常规讨论保守管理,并识别出五个主题:角色定义困难、回避临终对话、制度障碍、将保守管理视为「无治疗」以及道德困扰。道德困扰是推动讨论保守管理的关键因素。
要点
- 仅37%的肾内科医生常规与老年CKD患者讨论保守管理。
- 医生对角色认知和将保守管理视为「无治疗」影响讨论意愿。
- 道德困扰可促使医生更积极地讨论保守管理。
核心结论
- 道德困扰是推动肾内科医生讨论保守管理的催化剂,并可能解释美国保守管理使用率低的原因。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为访谈研究,纳入来自18个 practice 的35名美国肾内科医生,采用半结构化定性访谈直至主题饱和。
主要发现
- 37%的医生描述常规讨论保守管理(「早期采用者」)。
- 识别出5个主题:角色定义困难、回避临终对话、制度障碍、保守管理视为「无治疗」、道德困扰。
临床怎么用
- 肾内科医生应意识到道德困扰对讨论保守管理的影响,并注意制度障碍和角色认知对决策的作用。
局限性
- 参与者的观点可能主要适用于大型学术医疗中心,因为学术临床医生被过度抽样。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Although dialysis may not provide a large survival benefit for older patients with kidney failure, few are informed about conservative management. Barriers and facilitators to discussions about conservative management and nephrologists' decisions to present the option of conservative management may vary within the nephrology provider community. STUDY DESIGN: Interview study of nephrologists. SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: National sample of US nephrologists sampled based on sex, years in practice, practice type, and region. METHODOLOGY: Qualitative semistructured interviews continued until thematic saturation. ANALYTICAL APPROACH: Thematic and narrative analysis of recorded and transcribed interviews. RESULTS: Among 35 semistructured interviews with nephrologists from 18 practices, 37% described routinely discussing conservative management ("early adopters"). 5 themes and related subthemes reflected issues that influence nephrologists' decisions to discuss conservative management and their approaches to these discussions: struggling to define nephrologists' roles (determining treatment, instilling hope, and improving patient symptoms), circumventing end-of-life conversations (contending with prognostic uncertainty, fearing emotional backlash, jeopardizing relationships, and tailoring information), confronting institutional barriers (time constraints, care coordination, incentives for dialysis, and discomfort with varied conservative management approaches), conservative management as "no care," and moral distress. Nephrologists' approaches to conservative management discussions were shaped by perceptions of their roles and by a common view of conservative management as no care. Their willingness to pursue conservative management was influenced by provider- and institutional-level barriers and experiences with older patients who regretted or had been harmed by dialysis (moral distress). Early adopters routinely discussed conservative management as a way of relieving moral distress, whereas others who were more selective in discussing conservative management experienced greater distress. LIMITATIONS: Participants' views are likely most transferable to large academic medical centers, due to oversampling of academic clinicians. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings clarify how moral distress serves as a catalyst for conservative management discussion and highlight points of intervention and mechanisms potentially underlying low conservative management use in the United States.
引用
- Ladin K, Pandya R, Kannam A, et al. Discussing Conservative Management With Older Patients With CKD: An Interview Study of Nephrologists. Am J Kidney Dis. 2018. PMID: 29396240. doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2017.11.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。