影响印尼医生对透析与保守管理推荐的因素
该研究调查参加第九届亚洲慢性肾脏病倡议论坛的医生,使用不同年龄和合并症状态的病例情景,询问其推荐透析或保守管理(CM)及预测生存。结果显示医生对透析生存获益认知不一,治疗推荐存在高度不一致,且为自己推荐透析的可能性远高于为患者推荐。
要点
- 医生对透析是否延长生存的认知存在分歧,部分认为CM生存更优。
- 治疗推荐高度不一致:65岁糖尿病患者的透析推荐率为62%。
- 医生为自己选择透析的意愿远高于为患者推荐。
核心结论
- 医生对不同合并症老年ESRD患者的透析与CM生存获益理解不足,导致推荐不一致。
研究设计与样本
- 调查参加第九届亚洲慢性肾脏病倡议论坛的医生便利样本,使用不同年龄和合并症状态的病例情景。
主要发现
- 医生平均认为透析相对CM延长生命,但相当一部分认为CM生存更优。
- 认为CM生存更优的估计范围从17.3%(65岁伴糖尿病和充血性心力衰竭)到50%(晚期癌症)。
- 65岁糖尿病患者中62%推荐透析、38%不推荐;晚期癌症中25%推荐透析、75%不推荐。
- 医生为自己推荐透析的可能性远高于为患者推荐。
临床怎么用
- 医生应加深对透析与CM在不同合并症老年患者中生存获益的理解,以助患者知情决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: For elderly end-stage renal disease (ESRD) patients with multiple comorbidities, dialysis may offer little survival benefit compared to conservative management (CM). Yet, many elderly ESRD patients undergo dialysis, partly due to physicians' recommendations regarding treatment choice. This study aims to elucidate the factors that influence these recommendations. METHODS: We surveyed a convenience sample of physicians who attended the 9th Asian Forum of Chronic Kidney Disease Initiative conference. We used vignettes that vary by age and comorbidity status, and asked physicians to recommend dialysis or CM for a hypothetical patient with that profile and to predict survival with both treatment options. We also compared the physician's recommendations to patients for what they would recommend for themselves if they were diagnosed with ESRD. RESULTS: On average, physicians believed that dialysis extends life relative to CM. Yet, a large subset believed that CM confers greater survival. Estimates range from 17.3% (for a 65-year-old with diabetes and CHF) to 50% for patients with advanced cancer. Results further reveal high discordance regarding treatment recommendations. For a 65-year-old patient with diabetes, 62% recommended dialysis and 38% did not. For advanced cancer, the split was 25% and 75%. Physicians were far more likely to recommend dialysis for themselves than for their patients. DISCUSSION: This study suggests that physicians would benefit from a greater understanding of survival benefits of dialysis and CM for elderly patients with different comorbidity profiles. This would allow patients to make more informed decisions.
引用
- Finkelstein EA, Ozdemir S, Malhotra C, et al. Identifying Factors That Influence Physicians' Recommendations for Dialysis and Conservative Management in Indonesia. Kidney Int Rep. 2016. PMID: 29142957. doi:10.1016/j.ekir.2016.12.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。