文献速递血液净化与透析

美国与英国肾内科医生对放弃或撤除透析的系统层面障碍与促进因素:一项定性研究

System-Level Barriers and Facilitators for Foregoing or Withdrawing Dialysis: A Qualitative Study of Nephrologists in the United States and England.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Kidney Dis · 2017-02-24

该研究对来自美国和英格兰的59名肾内科医生进行半结构式个人定性访谈,探讨影响终末期肾病决策的因素。访谈发现,两国放弃和撤除透析的系统层面促进因素和障碍源于国家与机构政策、医疗实践文化及社会文化;主要障碍包括缺乏临终对话培训以及非肾内科医生和公众对积极治疗的期望,主要差异在于美国存在透析的经济激励而英格兰有广泛的门诊保守管理项目。

要点

  • 两国肾内科医生均描述缺乏临终对话培训是放弃或撤除透析的主要障碍。
  • 美国存在透析经济激励,英格兰有广泛的门诊保守管理项目,构成两国主要差异。
  • 系统层面因素既促进也干扰放弃和撤除透析的决策。

核心结论

  • 美国和英格兰的肾内科医生识别出若干系统层面因素,这些因素既促进也干扰围绕放弃和撤除透析治疗的决策。
  • 在扩大促进因素的同时减少障碍,可能使医疗实践更符合患者预后。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究采用半结构式、个人、定性访谈。
  • 参与者根据年龄、种族、性别、地理位置和执业类型进行目的性抽样。
  • 共访谈来自美国的41名和英格兰的18名肾内科医生,合计59名。
  • 访谈录音后转录,采用叙事分析和主题分析。

主要发现

  • 大多数参与者为45岁或以下、男性、白人;完成肾内科培训后的平均时间为14.2±11.6(标准差)年。
  • 两国放弃和撤除透析的系统层面促进因素和障碍源于国家和机构政策及结构性因素、医生行医方式(医学文化)以及公众的信念和行为(社会文化)。
  • 两国描述的主要障碍包括缺乏临终对话培训以及非肾内科医生和公众对积极治疗的期望。
  • 主要差异包括美国存在透析的经济激励,英格兰有广泛的门诊保守管理项目。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 参与者的观点可能无法完全代表所有美国或英格兰肾内科医生的观点。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Despite a growing body of literature suggesting that dialysis does not confer morbidity or mortality benefits for all patients with chronic kidney failure, the initiation and continuation of dialysis therapy in patients with poor prognosis is commonplace. Our goal was to elicit nephrologists' perspectives on factors that affect decision making regarding end-stage renal disease. STUDY DESIGN: Semistructured, individual, qualitative interviews. METHODOLOGY: Participants were purposively sampled based on age, race, sex, geographic location, and practice type. Each was asked about his or her perspectives and experiences related to foregoing and withdrawing dialysis therapy. ANALYTICAL APPROACH: Interviews were audiotaped, transcribed, and analyzed using narrative and thematic analysis. RESULTS: We conducted 59 semistructured interviews with nephrologists from the United States (n=41) and England (n=18). Most participants were 45 years or younger, men, and white. Average time since completing nephrology training was 14.2±11.6 (SD) years. Identified system-level facilitators and barriers for foregoing and withdrawing dialysis therapy stemmed from national and institutional policies and structural factors, how providers practice medicine (the culture of medicine), and beliefs and behaviors of the public (societal culture). In both countries, the predominant barriers described included lack of training in end-of-life conversations and expectations for aggressive care among non-nephrologists and the general public. Primary differences included financial incentives to dialyze in the United States and widespread outpatient conservative management programs in England. LIMITATIONS: Participants' views may not fully capture those of all American or English nephrologists. CONCLUSIONS: Nephrologists in the United States and England identified several system-level factors that both facilitated and interfered with decision making around foregoing and withdrawing dialysis therapy. Efforts to expand facilitators while reducing barriers could lead to care practices more in keeping with patient prognosis.

来源:Am J Kidney Dis,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Grubbs V, Tuot DS, Powe NR, et al. System-Level Barriers and Facilitators for Foregoing or Withdrawing Dialysis: A Qualitative Study of Nephrologists in the United States and England. Am J Kidney Dis. 2017. PMID: 28242134. doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2016.12.015

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。