维持性血液透析患者肌肉痉挛的发生率、严重程度与负担:一项为期一年的多中心质量改进项目
该质量改进项目在五个门诊透析中心对维持性血液透析患者每4周进行一次三题痉挛问卷(回顾1周),共420例患者完成中位9次问卷。结果显示62%至少报告一次痉挛,平均19%每4周报告痉挛,13%为频繁痉挛者;69%报告至少一次中重度疼痛,60%报告中度至极度困扰。结论提示约五分之一患者每4周报告痉挛且负担显著,但仅八分之一频繁痉挛。
要点
- 每4周问卷显示19%的透析患者报告痉挛,13%为频繁痉挛者。
- 69%患者至少一次痉挛为中重度疼痛,60%为中度至极度困扰。
- 同周疼痛与困扰评分相关(r=0.72,P<0.001)。
核心结论
- 每4周调查显示约五分之一血液透析患者报告肌肉痉挛且负担显著,但仅八分之一频繁痉挛。
- 频繁痉挛者可能适合作为初始预防干预试验的目标人群,同时需关注偶发痉挛但受困扰的患者。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心质量改进项目,在五个地理分布不同的门诊透析中心嵌入每4周重复的三题痉挛问卷(回顾1周),贯穿2024年。
- 420例维持性血液透析患者完成中位9次(IQR 7-11)问卷,按痉挛报告比例分为从不痉挛、偶发痉挛(<50%问卷报告痉挛)和频繁痉挛(≥50%)。
主要发现
- 420例中159例(38%)从未报告痉挛,208例(49%)为偶发痉挛,53例(13%)为频繁痉挛。
- 62%患者至少报告一次痉挛,平均19%(范围11%-25%)每4周报告痉挛。
- 69%患者至少一次痉挛为中重度疼痛,60%报告中度至极度困扰。
- 同周疼痛与困扰评分相关(0.72,P<0.001);相邻问卷间最大疼痛评分每增加1分,困扰评分增加0.74(P<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 可将每4周痉挛问卷嵌入常规透析 care 以识别频繁痉挛者。
- 频繁痉挛者可优先纳入预防痉挛的干预试验。
- 对偶发痉挛但受困扰的患者也需人群层面的干预措施。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
KEY POINTS: Identifying patients who cramp frequently over time is crucial for designing intervention studies to prevent cramping. One in five patients receiving hemodialysis reported muscle cramps every 4 weeks posing significant burden, although only one in eight patients cramped frequently In addition, population-based interventions are needed to address the high proportion of patients who are bothered by occasional cramps. BACKGROUND: Cramps are common in patients on dialysis, yet data on prevalence over time and patient burden are lacking. This quality improvement initiative evaluated the prevalence and natural history of muscle cramps to provide clinicians with baseline understanding of the magnitude and scope of cramping in patients on hemodialysis. METHODS: A recurring three-question cramps questionnaire with a 1-week recall period was embedded in routine care for patients on maintenance hemodialysis over five diverse, geographically distributed outpatient clinics to determine occurrence rate, pain severity, and burden from muscle cramps. This was repeated every 4 weeks during 2024. Prevalent patients completing ≥3 questionnaires were categorized as never-crampers, occasional crampers (<50% of responses with cramps), and frequent crampers (≥50% with cramps). The association between concurrent pain severity and bother scores (each ranging from 0 to 10) and changes in these scores were compared using linear regression. RESULTS: There were 420 patients who completed a median of nine (interquartile range, 7-11) questionnaires. Among this cohort, 159 (38%) never reported cramps, 208 (49%) reported occasional cramps, and 53 (13%) reported frequent cramps. Although 62% reported cramps at least once, on average, 19% reported cramps every 4-week period (range 11%-25%). Most patients (69%) reported at least one cramp episode as moderate to severely painful while 60% reported cramping as moderate to extremely bothersome. Pain and bother scores for the same week correlated (0.72, P < 0.001). Between consecutive questionnaires, each one-point increase in maximal pain score associated with a 0.74 increase in bother score ( P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Surveys done every 4 weeks showed that one in five patients on hemodialysis report muscle cramps with significant burden, although only one in eight cramp frequently. Although patients who cramp frequently may be appropriate targets for initial intervention trials to prevent cramps, additional interventions could address the high proportion of patients who are bothered by occasional cramps.
引用
- Lacson E, Li NC, Shieu M, et al. Muscle Cramp Rate, Severity, and Burden in Maintenance Hemodialysis Patients: A Yearlong Multicenter Quality Improvement Initiative. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2026. PMID: 42384454. doi:10.2215/CJN.0000001106
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。