肾衰竭患者死亡风险预测工具的开发:终端用户优先事项的名义群体技术研究
本研究通过改良名义群体技术召开在线共识研讨会,识别肾衰竭死亡风险预测工具终端用户的需求与偏好。
要点
- 终端用户优先考虑死亡风险预测工具在门诊与肾内科医生协商使用。
- 预测时间范围应个体化,并在临床状况变化后重新评估风险。
- 关键预测变量包括合并症、肾衰竭特征(如非计划透析开始)和衰弱状态。
核心结论
- 肾衰竭死亡预测工具的终端用户优先考虑工具的设计和使用方式,共同设计可能提高其可用性和采纳率。
研究设计与样本
- 采用改良名义群体技术的半日在线共识研讨会,招募来自加拿大各地的肾衰竭亲历者(患者和/或照护者)及肾衰竭管理相关医护人员和政策制定者。
主要发现
- 参与者优先考虑工具在门诊内与肾内科医生协商使用。
- 参与者优先考虑预测时间范围的个体化及临床状况变化后重新评估风险预测。
- 参与者优先考虑将合并症、肾衰竭特征(如非计划透析开始)和衰弱状态纳入关键预测变量。
- 转录分析识别出影响工具可用性的因素,包括提供者信任、讨论死亡风险的舒适度、患者隐私、随访和支持系统的可用性、患者准备度及纳入所需预测变量的可行性。
临床怎么用
- 未来工具开发应与终端用户偏好对齐,采用共同设计以增强可用性和 uptake。
局限性
- 基于媒体的招募和参与障碍可能限制了患者样本的代表性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Many mortality risk prediction models for individuals with kidney failure are available; however, their development did not involve end-users during the design process, and none are widely used in clinical practice. We identified the needs and preferences of end-users to inform the development and enhance the usability of a mortality risk prediction tool for people with kidney failure. STUDY DESIGN: A half-day, online consensus workshop was conducted using a modified nominal group technique. SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: People with lived experience of kidney failure (patients with or without receipt of kidney replacement therapy and their caregivers) or kidney failure management (health care providers and policymakers) recruited from across Canada. ANALYTICAL APPROACH: Preferences were elicited in 3 topic areas: the tool's intended use, timing (prediction horizon and update frequency), and relevant predictor variables. Conventional content analysis of discussion transcripts was conducted to elaborate on the findings. RESULTS: Eighteen individuals from across 5 provinces participated in the workshop, including 7 patients, 3 caregivers, and 8 health care providers or policymakers. Participants prioritized the following: (1) tool use within clinics and in consultation with nephrologists; (2) personalization of the prediction time horizons and reassessment of risk prediction following changes in clinical condition; and (3) inclusion of coexisting conditions, kidney failure characteristics (eg, unplanned dialysis start), and frailty status as key predictor variables. Analysis of transcripts identified several factors influencing the tool's usability, including provider trust, comfort in discussing mortality risk, patient privacy, availability of follow-up and support systems, patient readiness, and feasibility of incorporating desired predictor variables. LIMITATIONS: Media-based recruitment and participation barriers may have limited the representativeness of the patient sample. CONCLUSIONS: End-users of mortality prediction tools for people with kidney failure prioritized design and use considerations. Co-design of future tools to align with end-user preferences may enhance their usability and enhance their uptake. PLAIN-LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Many calculators predict survival for people with kidney failure on dialysis, but few are used in practice, in part because they were not created with input from people who need them. To learn what users want, we conducted an online consensus workshop involving individuals living with kidney failure, caregivers, clinicians, and policymakers from across Canada. The participants discussed how and when the tool should be used and on which factors the tool should be based. They prioritized the use of the tool during clinic visits, personalizing the prediction horizon, and taking into account health conditions and frailty. The participants emphasized the importance of trust, comfort in communication, and support systems when using the tool. Involving users in tool design may enhance its usability and adoption.
引用
- Liu P, Caffrey N, Donald M, et al. Development of a Mortality Risk Prediction Tool for People With Kidney Failure: A Nominal Group Technique Study of End-User Priorities. Am J Kidney Dis. 2026. PMID: 41722887. doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2025.12.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。