中东和北非冲突与非冲突环境中保守肾脏管理的比较研究
该研究通过2022年对17个阿拉伯语中东和北非国家肾内科医生的网络调查,比较冲突区与非冲突区对保守肾脏管理(CKM)的认知与实施差异。共334名受访者中,冲突区66人、非冲突区268人。冲突区透析更多由慈善资金支持(OR 4.22),获得姑息治疗的机会更少(OR 3.36),缺乏CKM培训和有限的项目可及性被视为实施障碍(OR分别为2.59和3.42),且对停止透析的道德和宗教不适感更强。
要点
- 冲突区肾内科医生报告获得姑息治疗的机会显著更少(OR 3.36)。
- 缺乏CKM培训和有限的项目可及性是冲突区实施CKM的主要障碍。
- 冲突区透析更多依赖慈善资金(OR 4.22),对停止透析的道德宗教不适感更强。
核心结论
- 冲突区与非冲突区在CKM实施上存在伦理、操作和可及性差异。
- 冲突区肾内科医生对停止透析的道德和宗教不适感更强。
研究设计与样本
- 2022年为期3个月、覆盖17个阿拉伯语中东和北非国家的网络调查。
- 共334名肾内科医生受访,冲突区66人,非冲突区268人。
主要发现
- 冲突区透析更多由慈善来源资助(OR 4.22;95%CI 1.36-13.07)。
- 冲突区获得姑息治疗的机会更少(OR 3.36;95%CI 1.3-8.68)。
- 缺乏CKM培训是实施障碍(OR 2.59;95%CI 1.24-5.38)。
- 有限CKM项目可及性是实施障碍(OR 3.42;95%CI 1.59-7.35)。
- 冲突区受访者更可能兼职工作且女性比例更低。
关键数值与推荐
- 冲突区透析慈善资助OR 4.22(95%CI 1.36-13.07)。
- 姑息治疗可及性OR 3.36(95%CI 1.3-8.68)。
- 缺乏CKM培训OR 2.59(95%CI 1.24-5.38)。
- 有限CKM项目可及性OR 3.42(95%CI 1.59-7.35)。
临床怎么用
- 在冲突地区应加强CKM培训并扩大CKM项目可及性。
- 需制定支持性伦理政策以促进程序正义和分配正义。
- 应努力加强姑息治疗服务以支持CKM实施。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Conflicts severely disrupt care for patients with kidney failure, often limiting access to dialysis. In these challenging settings, conservative kidney management (CKM) emerges as a compassionate alternative focused on quality of life and symptom relief. This study explores how conflict conditions shape nephrologists' perceptions and implementation of CKM across the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. A web-based survey was distributed across 17 Arabic-speaking MENA countries over 3 months in 2022. Responses were divided into two groups according to the country's conflict status. Of the 334 nephrologist respondents, 66 were practicing in conflict zones and 268 in nonconflict zones. Conflict zone respondents were more likely to work part-time and less likely to be female. Dialysis in conflict zones was more likely funded by charitable sources (odds ratio [OR], 4.22; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.36 to 13.07). Compared with nonconflict zones, nephrologists in conflict areas reported significantly less access to palliative care (OR, 3.36; 95% CI, 1.3 to 8.68) and cited lack of CKM training and limited access to CKM programs as barriers to its implementation (OR, 2.59; 95% CI, 1.24 to 5.38 and OR, 3.42; 95% CI, 1.59 to 7.35; respectively). While overall awareness of CKM was similar, those in conflict zones expressed greater moral and religious discomfort with withholding dialysis. These findings underscore important ethical, operational, and access-related disparities in CKM delivery in conflict zones in the MENA region. Addressing these gaps through supportive ethical policies focusing on procedural and distributive justice, increased nephrologists' awareness and training, and enhanced efforts to strengthen palliative care services are essential tools for establishing CKM as a viable and ethical approach for patients in conflict-affected regions.
引用
- Al-Makki A, Gunderman D, Luyckx V, et al. Conservative Kidney Management in the Middle East and North Africa: A Comparative Study of Conflict and Nonconflict Settings. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2025. PMID: 41348504. doi:10.2215/CJN.0000000900
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。