文献速递血液净化与透析

用于肾内科专科培训医师形成性评估的家庭血液透析客观结构化临床考试

A Home Hemodialysis Objective Structured Clinical Examination for Formative Assessment of Nephrology Fellows.
PubMed 文献 · Clin J Am Soc Nephrol · 2025-05-21

本研究开发并初步验证了一项家庭血液透析(HHD)形成性客观结构化临床考试(OSCE),用于评估肾内科专科培训医师对无并发症HHD患者启动治疗的临床能力。38名来自9个培训项目的专科培训医师参加考试,71%通过,其平均分及循证题得分均低于11名委员会认证的验证者(P<0.001)。OSCE可用于评估HHD课程及个体医师的基本HHD临床技能。

要点

  • 开发了含27项(31分)的HHD OSCE,涵盖7道循证/标准诊疗题,及格线为31分中得20分(65%)。
  • 38名专科培训医师中71%通过(Cronbach α=0.70),平均分低于验证者(21.5±4.0 vs 27.5±2,P<0.001)。
  • 仅42%的医师能说出HHD的4项潜在获益和2项风险,29%知道每周最低标准Kt/V目标。

核心结论

  • OSCE可作为评估专科培训医师开具HHD处方熟练度的形成性评估工具。
  • OSCE可用于评估HHD课程及个体医师的基本HHD临床技能。

研究设计与样本

  • 由一名肾内科专科培训医师和五名教师(其中三人从事HHD实践)开发OSCE,九人测试委员会(五人从事HHD实践,一名HHD照护伙伴)评估试题难度/相关性并确定及格分数。
  • 最终测试含27项(31分),其中7项为循证/标准诊疗题(9.5分),及格分数为31分中得20分(65%)。
  • 通过11名委员会认证志愿者(其中四人从事HHD实践)进行初步验证,并测试了来自9个培训项目的38名专科培训医师(21名第一年,17名第二年)。

主要发现

  • 所有试题的相关性中位数为「重要」或「必需」,内容效度指数为0.84。
  • 验证者总体平均分±SD为27.5±2(100%通过),kappa=0.83(95%CI 0.67至0.99),循证题得分为9.0±0.6。
  • 专科培训医师平均分±SD为21.5±4.0,低于验证者的27.5±2,P<0.001;其循证题得分为7.4±1.4,低于验证者的9.0±0.6,P<0.001。
  • 验证者循证/标准诊疗题正确率为88%,专科培训医师为62%(P<0.001)。
  • 42%的专科培训医师能说出HHD的4项潜在获益和2项风险;79%认识到纽扣孔穿刺置管的主要风险是感染;74%正确识别每周三次血液透析的最低单室Kt/V,29%知道每周最低标准Kt/V目标。

关键数值与推荐

  • 及格分数为31分中得20分(65%)。
  • 所有试题相关性中位数为「重要」或「必需」,内容效度指数为0.84。
  • 验证者kappa=0.83(95%CI 0.67至0.99)。
  • 专科培训医师Cronbach α=0.70,71%通过。

临床怎么用

  • OSCE可作为形成性评估工具,用于评估专科培训医师开具HHD处方的熟练度。
  • OSCE可用于评估HHD课程及个体医师的基本HHD临床技能。
  • 88%的受调查专科培训医师(25人中的22人)同意/强烈同意OSCE有助于自我评估熟练度。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

KEY POINTS: Because of low patient numbers and uneven geographical distribution, nephrology fellows may not have experience caring for home hemodialysis (HHD) patients. We developed and preliminarily validated a formative HHD objective structured clinical examination. The objective structured clinical examination may be used to assess HHD curriculum and basic HHD clinical skills in individual fellows. BACKGROUND: The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education requires graduating nephrology fellows demonstrate competence in home hemodialysis (HHD). Because low patient numbers may lead to training gaps, clinical experience may be enhanced using simulation. We designed and preliminarily validated a formative objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) assessing clinical care of an uncomplicated patient initiating HHD, using a unified model of construct validity. METHODS: The OSCE was developed by a nephrology fellow and five faculty (three practicing HHD). The nine-member test committee (five in HHD practice; one HHD care partner) assessed test item difficulty/relevance and determined passing scores. The final test consisted of 27 items (31 possible points); seven were evidence-based/standard-of-care questions (9.5 possible points). Passing score was 20 of 31 points (65%). Median relevance for all items was “important” or “essential.” Content validity index was 0.84. On preliminary validation by 11 board-certified volunteers (four practicing HHD), overall mean±SD score was 27.5±2 (100% passing), kappa=0.83 (95% confidence interval, 0.67 to 0.99). Validator evidence-based question score was 9.0±0.6. RESULTS: Thirty-eight fellows (9 programs, 21 first-year; 17 second-year) were tested. Seventy-one percent passed (Cronbach α=0.70). Fellows' mean±SD scores were lower than validators: 21.5±4.0 versus 27.5±2, P < 0.001, as were their scores on evidence-based questions: 7.4±1.4 versus 9.0±0.6, P < 0.001. Eighty-eight percent of evidence-based/standard-of-care questions were answered correctly by validators versus 62% by fellows (P < 0.001). Forty-two percent of fellows were able to name four potential benefits and two risks associated with HHD; 79% recognized that the primary risk of buttonhole cannulation was infection. Seventy-four percent correctly identified minimum single pool Kt/V for thrice-weekly hemodialysis, and 29% knew the minimum standard weekly Kt/V target. Eighty-eight percent of fellows surveyed (22 of 25) agreed/strongly agreed that the OSCE was useful in self-assessing proficiency. CONCLUSIONS: The OSCE may be used as a formative assessment of fellow proficiency in prescribing HHD.

来源:Clin J Am Soc Nephrol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jones JA, Tobin TW, Bermudez MC, et al. A Home Hemodialysis Objective Structured Clinical Examination for Formative Assessment of Nephrology Fellows. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2025. PMID: 40397521. doi:10.2215/CJN.0000000740

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。