新分配系统下 deceased donor 肾脏供体分配结果分析
研究描述了2015至2022年间美国等待名单上成人候选者的移植与死亡率变化。在249,145名新登记等待者中,180,039人至少获得一次供体 offer,其中37.7%接受 deceased donor 肾移植,14.7%接受活体供肾移植,7.4%在等待期间死亡,12.7%被移除,27.5%在研究结束时仍在等待。首次 offer 中位时间从2015年的20天降至2022年的5天,而匹配算法产生的总 offer 数从2015年的7,911,688次增至2022年的29,332,516次。
要点
- 等待期间死亡者中位接受25次 offer,被移除者中位接受22次。
- 首次 offer 中位时间从2015年20天降至2022年5天。
- 匹配算法总 offer 数从2015年7,911,688次增至2022年29,332,516次。
核心结论
- 研究结果强调当前分配算法存在低效,需要重新思考如何为等待患者优先分配 deceased donor 器官以最大化救命器官的合适利用率。
研究设计与样本
- 研究描述了2015年至2022年间等待名单上候选者的移植和死亡率,纳入249,145名新登记等待成人中至少获得1次 offer 的180,039人。
主要发现
- 在180,039名至少获得1次 offer 的候选者中,37.7%接受 deceased donor 肾移植,14.7%接受活体供肾移植,7.4%在等待名单上死亡,12.7%被移除,27.5%在研究结束时仍在等待。
- 候选者首次 offer 的中位天数从2015年的20天(7-48)下降至2022年的5天(2-13)。
- 等待名单上死亡的候选者在研究期间中位接受25次 offer(9-56),被移除的候选者中位接受22次 offer(8-53)。
- 匹配运行算法产生的总 offer 数(包括未利用肾脏的 offer)从2015年的7,911,688次急剧增加至2019年的13,682,914次,并增至2022年的29,332,516次。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: In the United States (US), disparities in access to kidney transplantation exist for waitlisted candidates with end-stage kidney disease. Meanwhile, changes in kidney allocation policy have been associated with a dramatic increase in the number of organ offers declined before an organ is successfully placed. METHODS: We describe transplant and mortality rates for waitlisted candidates from 2015 to 2022 following these allocation changes. RESULTS: Among 249,145 incident waitlisted adults, 180,039 received at least 1 offer and were included in the study. Of these, 37.7% received a deceased donor kidney allograft, 14.7% received a living donor allograft, 7.4% died while on the waiting list, 12.7% were removed, and 27.5% were still waitlisted by the study end period. Overall, candidates' median number of days to receiving their first offer declined from 20 (7-48) in 2015 to 5 (2-13) in 2022. Candidates who died while on the waiting list received a median of 25 (9-56) offers and candidates who were removed received a median of 22 (8-53) offers during the study period. The total number of offers generated by the match-run algorithm, including those from nonutilized kidneys, increased sharply from 7,911,688 offers in 2015 to 13,682,914 in 2019, and to 29,332,516 in 2022. CONCLUSION: These findings emphasize the inefficiencies inherent in our current allocation algorithms and the need to rethink how waitlisted patients are prioritized for a given deceased donor organ in order to maximize the probability of appropriate utilization of lifesaving organs .
引用
- Mohan S, Yu M, Maclay LM, et al. Outcomes for Patients With a Deceased Donor Kidney Offer in the New Allocation System. Kidney Int Rep. 2025. PMID: 40303214. doi:10.1016/j.ekir.2025.01.021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。