美国肾移植候选者致敏状态优先点数的校准
该研究利用2016年1月至2023年9月美国270,912名成人肾移植候选者数据,评估2014年肾分配系统基于cPRA%的滑动优先权重效果。结果显示cPRA% 80-85和90-95者6年 deceased donor 移植累积发生率分别为48%和53%,高于cPRA% 0-20的37%;高cPRA%与移植率正相关,但该关联受地区、性别、种族、透析时间及血型影响。结论提示当前权重可能过度优先高致敏者,需重新校准并兼顾弱势亚组。
要点
- 高致敏候选者6年 deceased donor 移植率高于低致敏者。
- 致敏与移植率的关联受地区、性别、种族等因素影响。
- 当前优先权重可能过度提升高致敏者移植机会,需重新校准。
核心结论
- 基于cPRA%的滑动优先权重可能过度提升高致敏候选者的优先需求并导致更高移植率,提示需重新校准以促进公平。
研究设计与样本
- 利用美国国家移植受者科学登记系统,纳入2016年1月至2023年9月登记的270,912名成人肾移植候选者。
- 采用多变量logistic模型分析致敏相关因素,并用累积发生率模型(考虑竞争风险)和多变量Cox模型评估 deceased donor 移植率。
主要发现
- cPRA%=80–85和90–95的候选者6年 deceased donor 移植累积发生率分别为48%和53%,cPRA%=0–20者为37%。
- 多变量模型中,高cPRA%候选者的 deceased donor 移植调整风险最高。
- 高cPRA%与移植调整率的关联受地区、性别、种族和族裔、既往透析时间及血型显著影响。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估肾移植候选者时,应认识到当前基于cPRA%的优先权重可能使高致敏者获得过度优先。
- 分配政策制定需重新校准优先权重,并考虑地区、性别、种族、透析时间及血型等弱势亚组。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
KEY POINTS: There are multiple factors associated with high sensitization levels among kidney transplant candidates, which differ by candidate sex. Since the initiation of the kidney allocation system, candidates with higher sensitization have higher rates of deceased donor transplantation. Priority points assigned to candidates associated with sensitization have led to inequities in access to deceased donor transplantation. BACKGROUND: A primary change to the national organ allocation system in 2014 for deceased donor kidney offers was to weight candidate priority on the basis of sensitization (i.e., calculated panel reactive antibody percentage [cPRA%]) using a sliding scale. Increased priority for sensitized patients could improve equity in access to transplantation for disadvantaged candidates. We sought to evaluate the effect of these weights using a contemporary cohort of adult US kidney transplant candidates. METHODS: We used the national Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients to evaluate factors associated with sensitization using multivariable logistic models and rates of deceased donor transplantation using cumulative incidence models accounting for competing risks and multivariable Cox models. RESULTS: We examined 270,912 adult candidates placed on the waiting list between January 2016 and September 2023. Six-year cumulative incidence of deceased donor transplantation for candidates with cPRA%=80–85 and 90–95 was 48% and 53%, respectively, as compared with 37% for candidates with cPRA%=0–20. In multivariable models, candidates with high cPRA% had the highest adjusted hazards for deceased donor transplantation. There was significant effect modification such that the association of high cPRA% with adjusted rates of deceased donor transplantation varied by region of the country, sex, race and ethnicity, prior dialysis time, and blood type. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that the weighting algorithm for highly sensitized candidates may overinflate the need for prioritization and lead to higher rates of transplantation. Findings suggest recalibration of priority weights for allocation is needed to facilitate overall equity in access to transplantation for prospective kidney transplant candidates. However, priority points should also account for subgroups of candidates who are disadvantaged for access to donor offers.
引用
- Schold JD, Tambur AR, Mohan S, et al. Calibration of Priority Points for Sensitization Status of Kidney Transplant Candidates in the United States. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2024. PMID: 38509037. doi:10.2215/CJN.0000000000000449
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。