慢性肾脏病大鼠经皮与估算肾小球滤过率存在显著差异
该回顾性研究在43只健康雄性大鼠和84只慢性肾脏病雄性大鼠中比较了经皮肾小球滤过率(tGFR,采用单室和三相室模型)与基于尿sinistrin清除率的估算肾小球滤过率(eGFR)。结果显示eGFR平均显著低于tGFR_1c和tGFR_3c(平均差异分别为855和216 μL/min),且仅20%和47%的测量值在彼此30%范围内;相对差异在GFR最低的大鼠中最大。作者指出tGFR技术本身的问题(信号测量、动力学描述、半衰期向tGFR的转换依赖分布容积)以及异氟烷麻醉的未知影响可能是差异原因,强调需更严格验证tGFR并可能调整技术。
要点
- 大鼠eGFR平均显著低于tGFR_1c和tGFR_3c,差异分别为855和216 μL/min。
- 仅20%(vs tGFR_1c)和47%(vs tGFR_3c)的测量值在彼此30%范围内。
- eGFR与tGFR的相对差异在GFR最低的大鼠中最大。
核心结论
- tGFR与eGFR在大鼠中测量结果严重不一致,需更严格验证tGFR并可能调整技术。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性比较研究,纳入43只健康雄性大鼠和84只慢性肾脏病雄性大鼠的历史队列。
- 比较tGFR(单室模型tGFR_1c和三相室模型tGFR_3c)与基于尿sinistrin清除率的eGFR。
主要发现
- eGFR平均显著低于tGFR_1c和tGFR_3c,平均差异分别为855和216 μL/min。
- 仅20%的eGFR与tGFR_1c测量值在彼此30%范围内,47%的eGFR与tGFR_3c测量值在彼此30%范围内。
- eGFR与tGFR的相对差异在GFR最低的大鼠中最高。
局限性
- tGFR存在技术问题:信号测量、信号动力学描述、半衰期向tGFR转换依赖分布容积。
- 测定mGFR时使用的异氟烷麻醉影响未知,是限制因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Accurate assessment of the glomerular filtration rate (GFR) is crucial for researching kidney disease in rats. Although validation of methods that assess GFR is crucial, large-scale comparisons between different methods are lacking. Both transcutaneous GFR (tGFR) and a newly developed estimated GFR (eGFR) equation by our group provide a low-invasive approach enabling repeated measurements. The tGFR is a single bolus method using FITC-labeled sinistrin to measure GFR based on half-life of the transcutaneous signal, whilst the eGFR is based on urinary sinistrin clearance. Here, we retrospectively compared tGFR, using both 1- and 3- compartment models (tGFR_1c and tGFR_3c, respectively) to the eGFR in a historic cohort of 43 healthy male rats and 84 male rats with various models of chronic kidney disease. The eGFR was on average considerably lower than tGFR-1c and tGFR-3c (mean differences 855 and 216 μL/min, respectively) and only 20 and 47% of measurements were within 30% of each other, respectively. The relative difference between eGFR and tGFR was highest in rats with the lowest GFR. Possible explanations for the divergence are problems inherent to tGFR, such as technical issues with signal measurement, description of the signal kinetics, and translation of half-life to tGFR, which depends on distribution volume. The unknown impact of isoflurane anesthesia used in determining mGFR remains a limiting factor. Thus, our study shows that there is a severe disagreement between GFR measured by tGFR and eGFR, stressing the need for more rigorous validation of the tGFR and possible adjustments to the underlying technique.
引用
- Pieters TT, Besseling PJ, Bovée DM, et al. Discrepancies between transcutaneous and estimated glomerular filtration rates in rats with chronic kidney disease. Kidney Int. 2024. PMID: 38514000. doi:10.1016/j.kint.2024.02.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。