1日活体肾供者评估项目的实施:供者候选人与利益相关者视角的定性分析
研究在渥太华医院开展1日活体肾供者评估流程,通过对18名供者候选人和13名利益相关者进行半结构化访谈,发现所有候选人均认为该流程省时且经济,多数认为可加速供者适合性判定,并建议评估日前安排护士和社工的虚拟访视以提供关键教育支持。
要点
- 1日评估流程被多数供者候选人偏好,被认为省时且经济。
- 评估日前护士和社工的虚拟访视提供关键教育与支持。
- 多数利益相关者强调候选者关怀和更快的适合性判定。
核心结论
- 1日评估流程被大多数供者候选人偏好,并被多数受访者认为省时且经济。
- 加速的1日评估可能加快供者适合性判定并提高活体供肾移植率。
研究设计与样本
- 对参与1日活体肾供者评估流程的供者候选人和实施策略关键利益相关者进行半结构化访谈。
- 采用定向内容分析,对利益相关者和供者候选人分别使用2个独特框架。
- 研究纳入13名利益相关者和18名供者候选人,其中16名(89%)为女性,7名(39%)继续进行了肾脏捐献。
主要发现
- 18名(100%)供者候选人认为该流程省时且经济,因减少旅行和误工时间。
- 13名(72%)供者候选人认为1日评估可能加速供者适合性判定。
- 评估日前护士和社工的序贯虚拟访视被视为提供关键教育和支持。
- 11名(85%)利益相关者强调供者候选人关怀和更快的适合性判定。
临床怎么用
- 1日评估流程可作为加速活体肾供者评估的可行模式,减少候选者时间与经济负担。
- 评估日前安排护士和社工的虚拟访视以提供教育和支持。
- 利益相关者重视候选者关怀和快速判定适合性,实施时需关注这些因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: A lengthy donor evaluation process hinders living donor kidney transplantation (LDKT). At The Ottawa Hospital, 1-day evaluation process was recently developed, with a goal to accelerate the determination of donor suitability. The major objective of this study was to solicit feedback from donor candidates and key stakeholders who participated in the 1-day living kidney donor evaluation process, to determine the program's acceptability and factors influencing its implementation elsewhere. METHODS: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with donor candidates who participated in the 1-day living kidney donor evaluation process, and with stakeholders who are instrumental to the implementation strategy. Interviews were conducted via videoconference or by telephone from May 2022 to December 2022. Directed content analysis was conducted using 2 unique frameworks for stakeholder and donor candidate interviews. RESULTS: Our study included 13 stakeholders and 18 donor candidates, of whom 16 (89%) were women and 7 (39%) proceeded to kidney donation. Eighteen (100%) perceived the process to be both time-effective and cost-effective, due to reduced travel and missed work time. Thirteen (72%) felt that the 1-day evaluation may accelerate determination of donor suitability. Sequential virtual sessions with a nurse and social worker in advance of the evaluation day were seen as providing critical education and support. Among stakeholders, 11 (85%) emphasized donor candidate care and faster candidacy determinations. CONCLUSION: The 1-day evaluation process was preferred by most donor candidates, and was perceived as time-effective and cost-effective by most interviewees. An expedited, 1-day evaluation may accelerate determination of donor suitability and improve LDKT rates.
引用
- Reid L, Mangalgi S, Mann G, et al. Implementation of a 1-Day Living Kidney Donor Evaluation Program: A Qualitative Analysis of Donor Candidate and Stakeholder Perspectives. Kidney Int Rep. 2023. PMID: 38344721. doi:10.1016/j.ekir.2023.11.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。