CKD就诊中的共享决策:患者决策角色偏好与体验
该横断面研究在荷兰2家医院纳入122例CKD患者,调查其在就诊后对决策角色的偏好与体验,并分析118段就诊录音中的共享决策行为。患者报告357项决策,其中151项体验与偏好不匹配;观察到的共享决策水平低(中位数4,范围0-22),动机性访谈技术很少使用。
要点
- CKD患者常报告规划、药物调整和生活方式改变等决策。
- 151/357项决策中患者体验与偏好角色不匹配。
核心结论
- CKD就诊中患者的偏好、体验与观察到的共享决策之间存在多重差异,相当多患者偏好共享决策但共享决策行为不常被观察到。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,纳入荷兰2家医院接受门诊治疗的CKD患者,就诊后行Control Preferences Scale调查(n=122),并对就诊录音用4SDM和动机性访谈编码工具评估(118项编码决策)。
主要发现
- 调查(n=122)中患者常报告规划(112/122)、药物调整(82/122)或生活方式改变(59/122)的决策。
- 357项报告决策中,患者偏好临床医生大部分决定125项、完全决定101项、共享决策116项。
- 151/357项决策中患者偏好与体验不匹配,其中体验为「较少共享/患者主导」76项、「较多共享/患者主导」75项。
- 118项编码决策中观察到的共享决策水平低(中位数4;范围0-22),动机性访谈技术很少使用。
临床怎么用
- 在CKD就诊中应关注患者对决策角色的偏好,并注意其体验可能与偏好不一致。
局限性
- 原文述潜在回忆偏倚和选择偏倚,以及普遍性有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RATIONALE & OBJECTIVE: Research on shared decision making (SDM) in chronic kidney disease (CKD) has focused almost exclusively on the modality of kidney replacement treatment. We explored what other CKD decisions are recognized by patients, what their preferences and experiences are regarding these decisions, and how decisions are made during their interactions with medical care professionals. STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional study. SETTING & PARTICIPANTS: Patients with CKD receiving (outpatient) care in 1 of 2 Dutch hospitals. EXPOSURE: Patients' preferred decisional roles for treatment decisions were measured using the Control Preferences Scale survey administered after a health care visit with medical professionals. OUTCOME: Number of decisions for which patients experienced a decisional role that did or did not match their preferred role. Observed levels of SDM and motivational interviewing in audio recordings of health care visits, measured using the 4-step SDM instrument (4SDM) and Motivational Interviewing Treatment Integrity coding tools. ANALYTICAL APPROACH: The results were characterized using descriptive statistics, including differences in scores between the patients' experienced and preferred decisional roles. RESULTS: According to the survey (n=122) patients with CKD frequently reported decisions regarding planning (112 of 122), medication changes (82 of 122), or lifestyle changes (59 of 122). Of the 357 reported decisions in total, patients preferred that clinicians mostly (125 of 357) or fully (101 of 357) make the decisions. For 116 decisions, they preferred a shared decisional role. For 151 of 357 decisions, the patients' preferences did not match their experiences. Decisions were experienced as "less shared/patient-directed" (76 of 357) or "more shared/patient-directed" (75 of 357) than preferred. Observed SDM in 118 coded decisions was low (median4; range, 0 - 22). Motivational interviewing techniques were rarely used. LIMITATIONS: Potential recall and selection bias, and limited generalizability. CONCLUSIONS: We identified multiple discrepancies between preferred, experienced, and observed SDM in health care visits for CKD. Although patients varied in their preferred decisional role, a considerable number of patients expressed a preference for shared decision making for many decisions. However, SDM behavior during the health care visits was observed infrequently. PLAIN-LANGUAGE SUMMARY: Shared decision making (SDM) may be a valuable approach for common chronic kidney disease (CKD) decisions, but our knowledge is limited. We collected patient surveys after health care visits for CKD. Patients most frequently experienced decisions regarding planning, medication, and lifestyle. Three decisional roles were preferred by comparable numbers of patients: let the clinician alone decide, let the clinician decide for the most part, or "equally share" the decision. Patients' experiences of who made the decision did not always match their preferences. In audio recordings of the health care visits, we observed low levels of SDM behavior. These findings suggest that the preference for "sharing decisions" is often unmet for a large number of patients.
引用
- van der Horst DEM, Hofstra N, van Uden-Kraan CF, et al. Shared Decision Making in Health Care Visits for CKD: Patients' Decisional Role Preferences and Experiences. Am J Kidney Dis. 2023. PMID: 37516297. doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2023.04.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。