六种运动干预对血液透析患者的疗效:随机临床试验的网络Meta分析
该系统综述与网络Meta分析纳入78项随机临床试验共3326例血液透析患者,比较五种透析中运动模式与家庭训练的效果。联合训练在提升峰值耗氧量和降低舒张压方面表现最佳,吸气肌训练最改善6分钟步行距离,抗阻训练降低C反应蛋白并改善SF-36躯体功能,有氧训练改善Kt/V并降低C反应蛋白。透析中运动与家庭训练均可获益,无证据显示任一模式优于其他模式。
要点
- 联合训练较常规护理组提升峰值耗氧量(MD=3.94 ml/kg/min)并降低舒张压(MD=-5.19 mmHg)。
- 吸气肌训练最改善6分钟步行距离(MD=70.97 m),抗阻训练降低C反应蛋白(MD=-2.6 mg/l)。
- 有氧训练改善Kt/V(MD=0.11)并降低C反应蛋白(MD=-1.4 mg/l),抗阻训练改善SF-36躯体功能(MD=10.66分)。
核心结论
- 透析中训练与家庭训练均可为血液透析患者带来获益,无证据显示任一训练模式优于其他模式。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与网络Meta分析,检索PubMed/MEDLINE、Cochrane Library、Embase、Cinahl和Scopus自建库至2022年9月19日。
- 纳入78项随机临床试验,共3326例参与者。
- 采用传统随机效应模型和贝叶斯网络Meta分析模型,使用RoB v.2.0工具评估偏倚风险,使用CINeMA工具评估结果置信度。
主要发现
- 与常规护理组相比,联合训练提升峰值耗氧量(MD=3.94 ml/kg/min;95%CrI 2.38至5.76)并降低舒张压(MD=-5.19 mmHg;95%CrI -9.35至-0.96)。
- 吸气肌训练最改善6分钟步行试验距离(MD=70.97 m;95%CrI 18.09至129.87)。
- 抗阻训练降低C反应蛋白(MD=-2.6 mg/l;95%CrI -4.97至-0.33),有氧训练降低C反应蛋白(MD=-1.4 mg/l;95%CrI -3.15至-0.06)。
- 有氧训练改善Kt/V(MD=0.11;95%CrI 0.02至0.18),抗阻训练改善SF-36躯体功能(MD=10.66分;95%CrI 1.91至20.22)。
- 亚组分析显示,运动干预>12周较≤12周更改善功能能力,联合训练仅在随访12周后降低舒张压;中等或中等至剧烈强度训练对功能能力改善更明显,而轻度或轻度至中度强度训练无同样效果。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 本综述中多数纳入研究被评为存在一些担忧,导致总体结果的置信度为低至极低。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Evidence comparing different exercise modalities in individuals undergoing hemodialysis remains incipient. Our aim was to conduct a systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials to compare and synthesize the efficacy of five different intradialytic exercise modalities and home-based training in this population. DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, AND MEASUREMENTS: Studies were searched in PubMed/MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, Embase, Cinahl, and Scopus from their inception to 19 September 2022. We used traditional random-effects models and Bayesian network meta-analysis models. The risk of bias was assessed using the RoB v.2.0 tool, and the assessment of confidence in the results through the Confidence in Network Meta-Analysis (CINeMA) tool. RESULTS: Seventy-eight studies involving 3326 participants were included. Our network meta-analysis showed that combined training was the intervention with the best performance to increase VO2 peak [mean difference (MD) = 3.94 ml/kg/min; 95% credible interval (CrI), 2.38 to 5.76] and to reduce diastolic blood pressure (MD = -5.19 mmHg; 95%CrI, -9.35 to -0.96) compared to the usual care group. Inspiratory muscle training was the intervention that most improved the 6-minute walk test distance (MD = 70.97 m; 95%CrI, 18.09 to 129.87). C-reactive protein decreased in resistance training (MD = -2.6 mg/l; 95%CrI, -4.97 to -0.33) and aerobic training (MD = -1.4 mg/l; 95%CrI, -3.15 to -0.06). Kt/V improved in aerobic training (MD = 0.11; 95%CrI, 0.02 to 0.18), and SF-36 physical functioning outcomes improved in resistance training (MD = 10.66 points; 95%Crl, 1.91 to 20.22). No intradialytic exercise modality was superior to others or comparable with home-based training in improving the evaluated outcomes. Subgroup analysis revealed that exercise interventions >12 weeks improved functional capacity more than interventions ≤12 weeks, and that combined training reduces diastolic blood pressure only after 12 weeks of follow-up. Furthermore, our results suggest that moderate or moderate-to-vigorous intensity training leads to more pronounced improvements in functional capacity, whereas mild or mild-to-moderate intensity training does not have the same effect. In this review, most of the included studies were assessed as having some concern, which resulted in a low to very low level of confidence in the overall findings. CONCLUSIONS: Both intradialytic training and home-based training can promote benefits for individuals undergoing hemodialysis, with no evidence of the superiority of either training modality over the other.
引用
- Ferrari F, Andrade FP, Teixeira MS, et al. Efficacy of six exercise-based interventions for individuals undergoing hemodialysis: a network meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2023. PMID: 37118876. doi:10.1093/ndt/gfad083
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。