跨初级和二级保健的复杂干预措施优化人群肾脏健康:一项系统综述和现实主义综合,以理解背景、机制和结局
该系统综述和现实主义综合纳入60项研究,探讨跨初级和二级保健的复杂干预措施如何通过背景-机制-结局相互作用优化慢性肾脏病(CKD)人群肾脏健康。关键干预成分包括初级保健中高风险病例的自动检测并给全科医生管理建议、教育支持和非面向患者肾脏科医生审核;这些成分在组织支持等背景下促进临床医生学习和动机,可能改善人群肾脏疾病和心血管结局,但缺乏患者视角。
要点
- 关键干预成分包括初级保健中高风险病例自动检测并给全科医生管理建议、教育支持和非面向患者肾脏科医生审核。
- 成功时这些成分促进临床医生在管理CKD患者过程中学习、增强采取循证管理的动机,并与现有工作流程动态整合。
- 在支持性背景下(组织支持、干预兼容性、地理考虑),这些机制有可能改善人群肾脏疾病结局和心血管结局。
核心结论
- 该系统综述和现实主义综合描述了复杂干预如何改善CKD照护的提供,为未来干预开发提供了框架。
- 纳入研究提供了对这些干预运作的见解,但现有文献缺乏患者视角。
研究设计与样本
- 现实主义综合,纳入两项现有系统综述的参考文献和数据库检索,由六名审查员基于个体研究生成背景-机制-结局配置长列表,并在小组会议中综合成整合模型。
- 检索识别3371项相关研究,纳入60项,多数来自北美和欧洲。
主要发现
- 关键干预成分包括初级保健中高风险病例的自动检测并给全科医生管理建议、教育支持和非面向患者肾脏科医生审核。
- 成功时这些成分促进临床医生在管理CKD患者过程中学习、增强采取循证CKD管理的动机,并与现有工作流程动态整合。
- 在支持性背景下(组织支持、干预兼容性、地理考虑),这些机制有可能改善人群肾脏疾病结局和心血管结局。
局限性
- 患者视角不可获得,因此未纳入本研究发现。
- 现有文献缺乏患者视角。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: CKD affects 850 million people worldwide and is associated with high risk of kidney failure and death. Existing, evidence-based treatments are not implemented in at least a third of eligible patients, and there is socioeconomic inequity in access to care. While interventions aiming to improve delivery of evidence-based care exist, these are often complex, with intervention mechanisms acting and interacting in specific contexts to achieve desired outcomes. METHODS: We undertook realist synthesis to develop a model of these context-mechanism-outcome interactions. We included references from two existing systematic reviews and from database searches. Six reviewers produced a long list of study context-mechanism-outcome configurations based on review of individual studies. During group sessions, these were synthesized to produce an integrated model of intervention mechanisms, how they act and interact to deliver desired outcomes, and in which contexts these mechanisms work. RESULTS: Searches identified 3371 relevant studies, of which 60 were included, most from North America and Europe. Key intervention components included automated detection of higher-risk cases in primary care with management advice to general practitioners, educational support, and non-patient-facing nephrologist review. Where successful, these components promote clinician learning during the process of managing patients with CKD, promote clinician motivation to take steps toward evidence-based CKD management, and integrate dynamically with existing workflows. These mechanisms have the potential to result in improved population kidney disease outcomes and cardiovascular outcomes in supportive contexts (organizational buy-in, compatibility of interventions, geographical considerations). However, patient perspectives were unavailable and therefore did not contribute to our findings. CONCLUSIONS: This systematic review and realist synthesis describes how complex interventions work to improve delivery of CKD care, providing a framework within which future interventions can be developed. Included studies provided insight into the functioning of these interventions, but patient perspectives were lacking in available literature. PODCAST: This article contains a podcast at https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/www.asn-online.org/media/podcast/CJASN/2023_05_08_CJN0000000000000136.mp3.
引用
- Taylor DM, Nimmo AM, Caskey FJ, et al. Complex Interventions Across Primary and Secondary Care to Optimize Population Kidney Health: A Systematic Review and Realist Synthesis to Understand Contexts, Mechanisms, and Outcomes. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2023. PMID: 36888919. doi:10.2215/CJN.0000000000000136
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。