活体肾捐献知情同意的三步模型:欧洲肾脏协会DESCaRTES工作组的建议
活体肾捐献使健康人承担风险以惠及他人,知情同意标准化备受关注。作者基于Elwyn等的三谈话共享决策模型,提出三步(3-S)模型,将知情同意分为团队谈话、选项谈话和决策谈话三个理想时机,并给出标准化建议,以实现标准化与个体化的整合。
要点
- 3-S模型将活体肾捐献知情同意分为团队谈话、选项谈话和决策谈话三个时机。
- 该模型旨在为肾内科医生和移植临床医生提供标准化与个体化结合的知情同意指导。
- 作者提出该模型尚需研究评估其在肾移植临床实践中的有效性。
核心结论
- 3-S模型成功实现了知情同意的标准化与个体化整合,使潜在捐献者获得以人为中心的方法。
- 研究将评估3-S模型在肾移植临床实践中的有效性。
研究设计与样本
- 欧洲肾脏协会DESCaRTES工作组的建议性文章,基于Elwyn等三谈话共享决策模型提出3-S模型。
主要发现
- 3-S模型每一步对应活体肾捐献者决策过程的三个理想时机:需要肾脏替代治疗之前(团队谈话);在本地肾内科单位或移植中心,评估开始前与移植临床医生和外科医生(选项谈话);整个评估过程中,在了解捐献不同方面后,尤其是有疑虑或犹豫时(决策谈话)。
- 基于3-S模型,作者提供了关于时机、内容、风险沟通方式和捐献前理解评估标准化的建议。
关键数值与推荐
- 3-S模型的三个步骤分别为团队谈话、选项谈话和决策谈话。
- 知情同意过程涉及时机、内容、风险沟通方式和捐献前理解评估的标准化建议。
临床怎么用
- 作者基于3-S模型为肾内科医生和移植临床医生提供标准化知情同意的概念和实践指导,涉及时机、内容、风险沟通方式和捐献前理解评估。
局限性
- 研究将评估3-S模型在肾移植临床实践中的有效性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Living donation challenges the ethical principle of non-maleficence in that it exposes healthy persons to risks for the benefit of someone else. This makes safety, informed consent (IC) and education a priority. Living kidney donation has multiple benefits for the potential donor, but there are also several known short- and long-term risks. Although complete standardization of IC is likely to be unattainable, studies have emphasized the need for a standardized IC process to enable equitable educational and decision-making prospects for the prevention of inequities across transplant centers. Based on the Three-Talk Model of shared decision-making by Elwyn et al., we propose a model, named 3-Step (S) Model, where each step coincides with the three ideal timings of the process leading the living donor to the decision to pursue living donation: prior to the need for kidney replacement therapy (team talk); at the local nephrology unit or transplant center, with transplant clinicians and surgeons prior to evaluations start (option talk); and throughout evaluation, after having learned about the different aspects of donation, especially if there are second thoughts or doubts (decision talk). Based on the 3-S Model, to deliver conceptual and practical guidance to nephrologists and transplant clinicians, we provide recommendations for standardization of the timing, content, modalities for communicating risks and assessment of understanding prior to donation. The 3-S Model successfully allows an integration between standardization and individualization of IC, enabling a person-centered approach to potential donors. Studies will assess the effectiveness of the 3-S Model in kidney transplant clinical practice.
引用
- Grossi AA, Sever MS, Hellemans R, et al. The 3-Step Model of informed consent for living kidney donation: a proposal on behalf of the DESCaRTES Working Group of the European Renal Association. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2023. PMID: 36702535. doi:10.1093/ndt/gfad022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。