体弱重病透析患者对血液透析体验与期望的性别差异
在3家医院透析单位对1年死亡风险>20%的重病透析患者进行混合方法研究,共54人(男36、女18)参与结构化访谈或问卷。男性更重视达成身体目标,女性更希望感觉良好;两性报告的症状评分均显著高于医护感知,女性差异更明显;>50%存在透析后悔,6/54(11%)称会选择不透析,女性更常报告抑郁(P=0.001)。
要点
- 重病透析患者中男性更重视达成身体目标,女性更希望感觉良好。
- 两性报告的症状评分均显著高于医护感知,女性差异更明显。
- >50%患者存在透析后悔,6/54(11%)称会选择不透析,女性更常报告抑郁(P=0.001)。
核心结论
- 不同性别在治疗决策方式和治疗期望优先级上不同,认识到这一点有助于制定个性化照护计划并改善重病肾病患者体验。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,在3家医院透析单位邀请1年死亡风险>20%的重病血液透析患者参与结构化访谈或独立填写相同问题的问卷,共54人(男36、女18),采用主题分析法分析数据。
主要发现
- 「想要继续活下去」是开始透析时最重要和基本的思维过程,恐惧也主导风险感知和决策。
- 男性更可能优先达成身体目标,女性优先希望感觉良好。
- 两性报告的症状评分均显著高于医护感知,女性差异更明显。
- >50%参与者存在透析后悔,6/54(11%)表示会选择完全不透析。
- 女性更可能报告感到抑郁(P=0.001)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Surprisingly few studies have explored the experiences of seriously unwell people with kidney disease on hemodialysis therapy: we conducted a mixed-methods study to investigate gender differences in illness experience, symptom burden, treatment considerations or expectations in this cohort. METHODS: Seriously unwell people on hemodialysis (1-year mortality risk of >20%) at 3 hospital-based units were invited to take part in a structured interview or to complete the same questions independently via a questionnaire. A total of 54 people took part (36 males, 18 females); data analysis was undertaken using a thematic approach. RESULTS: "Desire to keep living" is the most important and basic thought process when starting dialysis. Fear also predominates influencing risk assessment and decision-making. Once fear is managed, there are physical, social, practical and emotional issues to rationalize, but choice only seems possible if shared decision-making is part of the consultation.Gender differences were seen in perceived hopes and expectations of treatment. Males were more likely to prioritize achievement of physical goals, with females prioritizing a wish to feel well. Both genders reported significantly higher symptom scores than their health care provider perceived, however this difference was more marked in females. Dialysis regret existed in >50% of participants and 6 out of 54 (11%) stated that they would have chosen no dialysis at all. Females were more likely to report feeling depressed (P = 0.001). CONCLUSION: Different genders approach treatment decisions and prioritize treatment expectations differently. Recognizing this will allow personalized care plans to be developed and improve the experiences of seriously unwell people with kidney disease.
引用
- Beckwith H, Thomas N, Adwaney A, et al. Gender Differences in Experiences and Expectations of Hemodialysis in a Frail and Seriously Unwell Patient Population. Kidney Int Rep. 2022. PMID: 36531893. doi:10.1016/j.ekir.2022.08.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。