文献速递慢性肾脏病遗传性与小管间质肾病

三维超声与椭球超声测量常染色体显性多囊肾病总肾脏体积与磁共振成像的比较

Total Kidney Volume Measurements in ADPKD by 3D and Ellipsoid Ultrasound in Comparison with Magnetic Resonance Imaging.
PubMed 文献 · Clin J Am Soc Nephrol · 2022-04-05

这项单中心前瞻性研究纳入142例常染色体显性多囊肾病(ADPKD)患者,比较三维超声、超声椭球法和磁共振椭球法测得的总肾脏体积与磁共振手动分割法的差异。与磁共振手动分割法相比,磁共振椭球法、三维超声和超声椭球法均低估总肾脏体积(平均差异分别为-3%、-9%和-11%),Mayo Clinic影像分类误分类率分别为11%、21%和22%。三种方法预测高危Mayo Clinic影像分类(1C-1E)的阳性预测值均高(分别为96%、95%和98%),但三维超声和超声椭球法的阴性预测值和敏感度低于磁共振椭球法。

要点

  • 三维超声和超声椭球法测量ADPKD总肾脏体积的偏倚和变异性相似,准确性均低于磁共振椭球法。
  • 磁共振椭球法、三维超声和超声椭球法均低估总肾脏体积,平均差异分别为-3%、-9%和-11%。
  • 三种方法预测高危Mayo Clinic影像分类(1C-1E)的阳性预测值均高,但超声椭球法更简便易行。

核心结论

  • 三维超声和超声椭球法测量ADPKD总肾脏体积的偏倚和变异性相似,准确性低于磁共振椭球法。
  • 三种方法预测高危Mayo Clinic影像分类(1C-1E)的阳性预测值均高,但超声椭球法更简便易行。

研究设计与样本

  • 单中心前瞻性研究,纳入142例完成标准化三维超声和磁共振成像(MRI)检查的患者。
  • 比较三维超声和超声椭球法与MRI测得的總肾脏体积,采用Bland-Altman图评估一致性,并评估Mayo Clinic影像分类的误分类情况。

主要发现

  • 与MRI手动分割法相比,MRI椭球法、三维超声和超声椭球法均低估总肾脏体积,平均差异分别为-3%、-9%和-11%。
  • Mayo Clinic影像分类误分类率分别为MRI椭球法11%、三维超声21%、超声椭球法22%;误分类病例中多数被归入较低的Mayo Clinic影像分类(MRI椭球法16例中11例,三维超声30例中23例,超声椭球法31例中26例)。
  • 预测高危Mayo Clinic影像分类(1C-1E)的阳性预测值分别为MRI椭球法96%、三维超声95%、超声椭球法98%;特异度分别为96%、96%、99%。
  • 阴性预测值分别为MRI椭球法90%、三维超声88%、超声椭球法95%;敏感度分别为88%、85%、94%,三维超声和超声椭球法低于MRI椭球法。
  • 平均超声肾脏长度>16.5 cm仅在年龄≤45岁患者中高度预测Mayo Clinic影像分类1C-1E。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Total kidney volume is a validated prognostic biomarker for autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease. Total kidney volume by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and manual segmentation is considered the "reference standard," but it is time consuming and not readily accessible. By contrast, three-dimensional (3D) ultrasound provides a promising technology for total kidney volume measurements with unknown potential. Here, we report a comparative study of total kidney volume measurements by 3D ultrasound versus the conventional methods by ultrasound ellipsoid and MRI ellipsoid. DESIGN, SETTING, PARTICIPANTS, & MEASUREMENTS: This single-center prospective study included 142 patients who completed a standardized 3D ultrasound and MRI. Total kidney volumes by 3D ultrasound and ultrasound ellipsoid were compared with those by MRI. We assessed the agreement of total kidney volume measurements by Bland-Altman plots and misclassification of the Mayo Clinic imaging classes between the different imaging methods, and we assessed prediction of Mayo Clinic imaging classes 1C-1E by average ultrasound kidney length >16.5 cm. RESULTS: Compared with MRI manual segmentation, MRI ellipsoid, 3D ultrasound, and ultrasound ellipsoid underestimated total kidney volume (mean difference: -3%, -9%, and -11%, respectively), with Mayo Clinic imaging classes misclassified in 11%, 21%, and 22% of patients, respectively; most misclassified cases by MRI ellipsoid (11 of 16), 3D ultrasound (23 of 30), and ultrasound ellipsoid (26 of 31) were placed into a lower Mayo Clinic imaging class. Predictions of the high-risk Mayo Clinic imaging classes (1C-1E) by MRI ellipsoid, 3D ultrasound, and ultrasound ellipsoid all yielded high positive predictive value (96%, 95%, and 98%, respectively) and specificity (96%, 96%, and 99%, respectively). However, both negative predictive value (90%, 88%, and 95%, respectively) and sensitivity (88%, 85%, and 94%, respectively) were lower for 3D ultrasound and ultrasound ellipsoid compared with MRI ellipsoid. An average ultrasound kidney length >16.5 cm was highly predictive of Mayo Clinic imaging classes 1C-1E only in patients aged ≤45 years. CONCLUSIONS: Total kidney volume measurements in autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease by 3D ultrasound and ultrasound ellipsoid displayed similar bias and variability and are less accurate than MRI ellipsoid. Prediction of high-risk Mayo Clinic imaging classes (1C-1E) by all three methods provides high positive predictive value, but ultrasound ellipsoid is simpler to use and more readily available.

来源:Clin J Am Soc Nephrol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Akbari P, Nasri F, Deng SX, et al. Total Kidney Volume Measurements in ADPKD by 3D and Ellipsoid Ultrasound in Comparison with Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol. 2022. PMID: 35383043. doi:10.2215/CJN.14931121

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。