测量英国肾脏服务中的患者体验:Kidney PREM 的开发与验证
为评估任何 CKD 分期或治疗方式(移植、血液透析、腹膜透析)患者的肾脏服务体验,研究分两阶段开发并验证 Kidney PREM。基于 2016-2018 年三次全国数据收集共分析 32 959 份回答,最终版含 38 个条目、13 个主题,Cronbach's α=0.94;简版含 15 个条目、覆盖相同 13 个主题。
要点
- Kidney PREM 最终版含 38 个条目、13 个主题,Cronbach's α=0.94。
- 简版含 15 个条目,覆盖与完整版相同的 13 个主题。
- 2018 年数据收集覆盖英国全部 71 个肾脏中心。
核心结论
- Kidney PREM 支持收集可靠的患者体验信息,且 CKD 患者认为这些信息与其相关,不受 CKD 分期或治疗方式影响。
- Kidney PREM 数据有潜力指导地方和国家层面的举措,以改善英国及其他国家患者对肾脏服务的体验。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分两阶段开发 Kidney PREM,由多学科专家组参与以确保表面效度。
- 组织三次全国数据收集(2016-2018 年),分析条目反应概况,并进行探索性和验证性分析以评估内部一致性。
- 通过认知访谈探索内容效度,并评估重测信度。
- 开发 Kidney PREM 简版,用于更频繁地测量患者体验以支持本地服务改进。
主要发现
- 共分析三次数据收集的 32 959 份回答,其中 2018 年收集覆盖英国全部 71 个肾脏中心。
- Kidney PREM 最终版由 38 个条目组成,归为 13 个主题,均属于反映「患者体验」构念的单一潜在维度,内部一致性高(Cronbach's α=0.94)。
- Kidney PREM 简版由 15 个条目组成,覆盖相同的 13 个主题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patient experience is a recognized aspect of quality of care for people with chronic kidney disease (CKD), but current patient-reported experience measures (PREMs) only focus on dialysis care. We developed and validated the Kidney PREM to assess patients' experience with renal services in secondary care for any CKD stage or treatment (transplant, haemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis). METHODS: We developed the Kidney PREM in two phases, informed by a multidisciplinary expert group to ensure face validity. We organized three national data collections (2016-8) to investigate item response profiles and to conduct exploratory and confirmatory analyses to assess internal consistency. We also explored content validity in cognitive interviews and evaluated test-retest reliability. Finally, we developed the Kidney PREM Short Form for more frequent measurement of patient experience to inform local service improvements. RESULTS: We analysed 32 959 responses across data collections, with the 2018 collection covering all 71 UK renal centres. The Kidney PREM final version consisted of 38 items grouped into 13 themes, all pertaining to one underlying dimension reflecting the construct of 'patient experience' with high internal consistency (Cronbach's α = 0.94). The Kidney PREM Short Form consisted of 15 items across the same 13 themes. CONCLUSIONS: The Kidney PREM supports the collection of reliable information on patient experience that people with CKD consider relevant, regardless of CKD stage or treatment modality. Kidney PREM data have the potential to guide local and national initiatives to improve patients' experiences with renal services in the UK and other countries.
引用
- Hawkins J, Wellsted D, Corps C, et al. Measuring patients' experience with renal services in the UK: development and validation of the Kidney PREM. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2022. PMID: 35138389. doi:10.1093/ndt/gfac030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。