共识定义对光镜与电镜识别肾小球病变的影响
2020年13名肾脏病理学家工作组发布47个光镜和47个电镜肾小球病变及9个正常结构的共识定义。通过两轮调查(第一轮297人,第二轮181人)测试定义对病变识别的影响。第二轮总体与共识答案一致率从65.2%升至72.0%(P=0.097),阅读定义者一致率更高(65.2% vs 74.8%,P=0.026)。结论:共识定义发表适度提高了观察者间一致性。
要点
- 共识定义发表后,与共识答案的平均一致率从65.2%升至72.0%,差异未达统计学显著(P=0.097)。
- 阅读定义原文的受访者一致率显著高于未阅读者(66.9% vs 74.8%,P<0.0001)。
- 仅纳入阅读定义的第二轮受访者时,一致率从65.2%升至74.8%(P=0.026)。
核心结论
- 共识定义的发表适度提高了肾小球病变识别的观察者间一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 2020年由13名肾脏病理学家组成的工作组发布47个光镜肾小球病变和47个电镜肾小球病变及9个正常结构的共识定义。
- 两轮调查发送给肾脏病理学会(RPS)所有成员,每轮含32张图像(19张光镜、13张电镜)及配套选择题,每题5个选项,其中1个为工作组共识答案。
- 第一轮调查于2020年9月发送,在共识定义发表前,297名RPS成员作答。
- 第二轮调查于2020年4月发送,在定义发表后5个月,使用相同病变和结构但不同图像及相同问题(选项顺序不同),181名RPS成员作答。
主要发现
- 两轮调查与共识答案的平均一致率从65.2%升至72.0%(P=0.097)。
- 仅纳入阅读定义原文的第二轮受访者时,一致率从65.2%升至74.8%(P=0.026)。
- 第二轮中,阅读定义原文者与未阅读者的一致率分别为74.8%和66.9%(P<0.0001)。
- 第二轮受访者中64%也参加了第一轮,61%报告已阅读定义原文。
关键数值与推荐
- 光镜共识定义涵盖47个肾小球病变。
- 电镜共识定义涵盖47个肾小球病变和9个正常结构。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: In 2020, a working group of 13 renal pathologists published consensus definitions for 47 individual glomerular lesions found on light microscopy (LM) and 47 glomerular lesions and 9 normal structures found on electron microscopy (EM). METHODS: To test the impact of these definitions on identification of these lesions and structures, 2 surveys were circulated to all members of the Renal Pathology Society (RPS), each having 32 images (19 LM, 13 EM) and accompanying questions with 5 multiple-choice answers, one being the consensus choice of the working group. The first survey (survey 1 [S1]), answered by 297 RPS members, was sent in September 2020, before publication of the consensus definitions. The second (survey 2 [S2]), with images of the same lesions and structures (but not the same images) and the same questions and multiple choices in different order, was sent in April 2020, 5 months after the publication of the definitions. RESULTS: S2 was taken by 181 RPS members; 64% also took S1 and 61% reported having read the definitions paper (def. paper). Mean agreement with the consensus answers increased modestly between the 2 surveys (65.2% vs. 72.0%, P = 0.097); the increase was greater and significant when only respondents to S2 who read the def. paper were considered (65.2% vs. 74.8%, P = 0.026). Furthermore, in S2 agreement with consensus answers was greater among respondents who read this paper versus those who did not (66.9% vs. 74.8%, P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Publication of the consensus definitions modestly improved interobserver agreement in identification of glomerular lesions.
引用
- Haas M, Mirocha J, Amann K, et al. Impact of Consensus Definitions on Identification of Glomerular Lesions by Light and Electron Microscopy. Kidney Int Rep. 2021. PMID: 35005316. doi:10.1016/j.ekir.2021.10.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。