四种SARS-CoV-2即时抗原检测方法的分析灵敏度与特异性评估
该研究以RT-qPCR为参考方法,评估四种SARS-CoV-2快速抗原检测试剂(Ag RDT)的分析灵敏度和特异性,并用ddPCR和质谱抗原法进一步表征样本。结果显示所有Ag RDT特异性接近100%,总体分析灵敏度为66.5%至88.3%,在病毒载量低于500 000 copies/mL时灵敏度差异显著。
要点
- 四种Ag RDT对RT-qPCR的特异性均接近100%。
- 总体分析灵敏度范围为66.5%至88.3%。
- 病毒载量低于500 000 copies/mL时,各Ag RDT灵敏度差异显著。
核心结论
- 四种SARS-CoV-2快速抗原检测试剂的分析灵敏度存在显著差异,尤其在病毒载量低于500 000 copies/mL时。
主要发现
- 所有Ag RDT相较于RT-qPCR的特异性均接近100%。
- 总体分析灵敏度为66.5%至88.3%。
- 所有方法均可检测病毒载量>1 500 000 copies/mL的样本抗原,对病毒载量500 000至1 500 000 copies/mL的样本检出率≥75%。
- 病毒载量50 000至500 000 copies/mL时,BD Veritor LF仅检出25%样本,ACON LF为75%,LumiraDx和ACON FIA>80%。
- 病毒载量<50 000 copies/mL且抗原可检出的样本中,Ag RDT灵敏度为13.0%(BD Veritor)至78.3%(ACON FIA)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We evaluated the analytical sensitivity and specificity of 4 rapid antigen diagnostic tests (Ag RDTs) for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2, using reverse transcription quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) as the reference method and further characterizing samples using droplet digital quantitative PCR (ddPCR) and a mass spectrometric antigen test. METHODS: Three hundred fifty (150 negative and 200 RT-qPCR positive) residual PBS samples were tested for antigen using the BD Veritor lateral flow (LF), ACON LF, ACON fluorescence immunoassay (FIA), and LumiraDx FIA. ddPCR was performed on RT-qPCR-positive samples to quantitate the viral load in copies/mL applied to each Ag RDT. Mass spectrometric antigen testing was performed on PBS samples to obtain a set of RT-qPCR-positive, antigen-positive samples for further analysis. RESULTS: All Ag RDTs had nearly 100% specificity compared to RT-qPCR. Overall analytical sensitivity varied from 66.5% to 88.3%. All methods detected antigen in samples with viral load >1 500 000 copies/mL RNA, and detected ≥75% of samples with viral load of 500 000 to 1 500 000 copies/mL. The BD Veritor LF detected only 25% of samples with viral load between 50 000 to 500 000 copies/mL, compared to 75% for the ACON LF device and >80% for LumiraDx and ACON FIA. The ACON FIA detected significantly more samples with viral load <50 000 copies/mL compared to the BD Veritor. Among samples with detectable antigen and viral load <50 000 copies/mL, sensitivity of the Ag RDT varied between 13.0% (BD Veritor) and 78.3% (ACON FIA). CONCLUSIONS: Ag RDTs differ significantly in analytical sensitivity, particularly at viral load <500 000 copies/mL.
引用
- Karon BS, Donato LJ, Bridgeman AR, et al. Analytical Sensitivity and Specificity of Four Point of Care Rapid Antigen Diagnostic Tests for SARS-CoV-2 Using Real-Time Quantitative PCR, Quantitative Droplet Digital PCR, and a Mass Spectrometric Antigen Assay as Comparator Methods. Clin Chem. 2021. PMID: 34240163. doi:10.1093/clinchem/hvab138
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。