三种商业连续监测血培养系统在儿童与标准培养基中的微生物检测及阳性时间比较
该研究比较了Virtuo、VersaTrek和Bactec FX三种血培养系统在标准与儿童培养基中的性能,使用模拟血培养评估不同血量对检测率和阳性时间的影响。结果显示检测率不受血量影响,但Virtuo对需氧菌的平均阳性时间较VersaTrek和Bactec缩短,儿童培养基在低血量时可能缩短阳性时间。
要点
- 检测率不受血量影响,但部分需氧菌检测率有差异。
- Virtuo对需氧菌平均阳性时间比VersaTrek短2.3小时,比Bactec短4.9小时。
- 低血量(<5 ml)时儿童培养基在VersaTrek或Bactec上可能缩短阳性时间。
核心结论
- Virtuo对许多血流感染相关微生物的阳性时间较VersaTrek和Bactec缩短,但可能存在菌种特异性限制。
研究设计与样本
- 使用模拟血培养,将三种革兰阳性菌、四种革兰阴性菌和一种厌氧菌(终浓度0.5至19 CFU/ml血液)接种于Virtuo、VersaTrek和Bactec FX系统,分别使用FAN Plus、Redox和Bactec Plus培养基,每种组合评估1、3、5、10 ml血量,各做三份重复。
主要发现
- 检测率不受血量影响。
- 需氧菌中检测率有差异的包括Kingella kingae、Haemophilus influenzae和Neisseria meningitidis。
- Bacteroides fragilis在Virtuo、VersaTrek和Bactec厌氧瓶中的检测率分别为83%、100%和100%。
- Virtuo标准培养基对需氧菌的平均阳性时间较VersaTrek缩短2.3小时,较Bactec缩短4.9小时。
- 与标准培养基相比,Virtuo的检测率和阳性时间无变化;Bactec儿童培养基对2/8种微生物缩短阳性时间,VersaTrek对7/8种微生物缩短阳性时间。
临床怎么用
- 当采集血量低于5 ml时,在VersaTrek或Bactec系统上使用儿童培养基可能缩短阳性时间。
- Virtuo系统对许多血流感染相关微生物的阳性时间较短,但需注意菌种特异性限制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
New blood culture instrumentation and medium formulations have led to improved time to positivity (TTP) for positive blood cultures. Data regarding the necessity of pediatric blood culture bottles with contemporary blood culture systems are sparse. We compared performance of three commercial blood culture systems, evaluating impact of blood volumes in standard and pediatric blood culture media across systems. Simulated blood cultures with packed red blood cells (PRBCs) and three Gram-positive, four Gram-negative, and one anaerobic organism (final concentrations ranging from 0.5 to 19 CFU/ml blood) on the Virtuo, VersaTrek, and Bactec FX instruments were evaluated with FAN Plus, Redox, and Bactec Plus media, respectively. For each medium/instrument/organism combination, 1-, 3-, 5-, and 10-ml blood volumes were evaluated in triplicate. Detection rate was not affected by blood volume. Aerobic organisms that demonstrated variable rates of detection were Kingella kingae, Haemophilus influenzae, and Neisseria meningitidis. Bacteroides fragilis was detected in 83%, 100%, and 100% of Virtuo, VersaTrek, and Bactec anaerobic bottles, respectively. The average TTP of standard medium for aerobic organisms detected on Virtuo was decreased compared to those for VersaTrek (-2.3 h) and Bactec (-4.9 h). Compared to standard medium, detection rate and TTP were unchanged on Virtuo, while TTP was reduced with pediatric medium for 2/8 organisms tested on Bactec and 7/8 organisms on VersaTrek, illustrating the potential benefit of pediatric medium on VersaTrek or Bactec when low blood volumes (<5 ml) are collected. These results demonstrate that TTP is decreased on the Virtuo compared to VersaTrek and Bactec for many microorganisms associated with bloodstream infection (BSI) but may have species-specific limitations.
引用
- Yarbrough ML, Wallace MA, Burnham CD, et al. Comparison of Microorganism Detection and Time to Positivity in Pediatric and Standard Media from Three Major Commercial Continuously Monitored Blood Culture Systems. J Clin Microbiol. 2021. PMID: 33910963. doi:10.1128/JCM.00429-21
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。