跨水平质控规则的成本与收益
该研究通过计算机模拟和实验室质控数据,评估跨水平(CL)质控规则在两级质控物多规则方案中对检测时间及假阳性率的影响。结果显示,CL规则可提高对小偏移(约1个标准差)的检出率,但也增加假阳性率,且当水平间偏移相关性高时影响更大。研究认为难以界定获益大于成本的情形,建议探索其他质控方法。
要点
- CL规则提高小偏移检出率但增加假阳性率。
- 水平间偏移相关性高时CL规则影响更大。
- 难以确定CL规则获益大于成本的情形。
核心结论
- CL规则有提高检出率的潜力,但也会增加假阳性率。
- 难以识别增加检测的获益超过假阳性成本的情形。
- 应探索替代的质控方法。
研究设计与样本
- 采用计算机模拟研究CL规则对检测时间和假阳性率的影响。
- 系统使用多规则(3-1s、2-2s、4-1s和10x)及2个水平的质控物。
- 还研究了各水平间偏移相关性的影响。
- 通过模拟分析比较质控政策的性能。
- 使用实验室质控数据比较质控政策(含与不含CL规则)的检出率。
主要发现
- 实施CL规则增加了假阳性率。
- 实施CL规则提高了对小偏移(约1个标准差)的检出率。
- 当水平间偏移相关性高时,CL规则的影响更大。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Quality is often monitored by multi-rule schemes that are applied at each level of QC material. Cross Level (CL) quality control rules have been proposed but have not been investigated. METHODS: We used computer simulation to study the impact of CL rules on time to detection and the false positive rate in a system using multirules (3-1s, 2-2s, 4-1s, and 10x) with 2 levels of QC material We also studied the effect of correlation between shifts at each level. The performance of QC policies was compared using simulation analysis. We also compared the detection rates of QC policies (with and without QC rules) using laboratory QC data. RESULTS: Implementing the CL rule increased the false positive rate and increased the detection rate for small shifts (around 1 standard deviation). CL rules had a greater impact when the correlation of shifts between levels was high. CONCLUSIONS: CL rules have the potential to increase detection rates, but also increase false positive rates. It is difficult to identify the circumstances where the benefits of increased detection outweigh the costs of false positives. Alternative approaches to QC should be explored.
引用
- Schmidt RL, Moore RA, Pearson LN, et al. The costs and benefits of cross-level quality control rules. Clin Chim Acta. 2020. PMID: 32910975. doi:10.1016/j.cca.2020.09.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。