独立验证自动审核限对分析前和分析误差检测性能的方法
该研究提出一种实验室特异性方法,独立验证自动审核限对分析前和分析误差的检测性能,使用MA Generator运行误差检测模拟,评估不同上下限检查的报警率和误差检测概率,并以血红蛋白、钠和钙为例获得具体限值。结论支持基于报警率和误差检测性能选择并验证最优自动审核限。
要点
- 自动审核限可分别验证分析前和分析误差检测性能。
- 分析前误差检测定义为一次错误结果内触发限检查报警,概率≥97.5%。
- 分析误差检测定义为计划内部QC测量间隔内触发报警,概率≥97.5%。
核心结论
- 所获得的上下限检查报警率和误差检测性能支持有依据地选择并验证最优自动审核限。
研究设计与样本
- 使用MA Generator运行误差检测模拟,评估不同上限检查和下限检查。
主要发现
- 限检查对分析前误差检测和较大分析误差的快速检测优于移动均值质控,但报警数量显著更多。
关键数值与推荐
- 分析前误差检测概率≥97.5%定义为一次错误结果内触发限检查报警,分析误差检测概率≥97.5%定义为计划内部QC测量间隔内触发报警。
- 血红蛋白分析前误差检测下限检查和上限检查分别≥-55%和>60%,分析误差检测分别≥-4%和≥15%。
- 钠分析前误差检测下限检查和上限检查分别≥-10%和≥20%,分析误差检测分别≥-3%和≥4%。
- 钙分析前误差检测下限检查和上限检查分别≥-40%和≥50%,分析误差检测分别≥-30%和≥25%。
临床怎么用
- 实验室可参考该方法独立验证自动审核限对分析前和分析误差的检测性能,并据报警率选择限值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Auto-verification limits are widely used to trigger confirmatory actions to enable detection of pre-analytical, analytical and post-analytical errors. An approach is presented for validating auto-verification limit performance in a laboratory-specific manner, independently for pre-analytical and analytical error detection. METHODS: To evaluate this approach, MA Generator (www.huvaros.com) was used to run error-detection simulations using various upper-limit checks (ULC) and lower-limit checks (LLC). Pre-analytical error detection was defined as triggering of a limit check alarm within one erroneous result. Analytical error detection was defined as triggering a limit check alarm within the scheduled internal QC measurement interval, both with ≥97.5% probability. Furthermore, the limit check alarm rates were obtained. RESULTS: Pre-analytical error detection and rapid detection of larger analytical errors by limit checks outperformed moving average quality control at the cost of a significantly larger number of alarms. A pre-analytical error detection by LLC and ULC of ≥-55% and >60%, ≥-10% and ≥20%, and ≥-40% and ≥50% and an analytical error detection of ≥-4% and ≥15%, ≥-3% and ≥4% and ≥-30% and ≥25% were obtained for hemoglobin, sodium and calcium, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The obtained ULC and LLC alarm rate and error detection performance, enabled substantiated selection of optimal auto-verification limits and validation thereof.
引用
- van Rossum HH. An approach to selecting auto-verification limits and validating their error detection performance independently for pre-analytical and analytical errors. Clin Chim Acta. 2020. PMID: 32416173. doi:10.1016/j.cca.2020.05.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。