阴道炎的分子诊断:定量PCR与微生物组谱分析对比现行显微镜评分
该横断面研究纳入93名女性,比较显微镜检查与两种分子方法(综合定量PCR和16S rRNA微生物组谱分析)对阴道炎的诊断。显微镜加Nugent评分与qPCR加BV解读算法总体一致率为76%;qPCR揭示38%BV、10%AV、5%假丝酵母、2%性传播感染、10%混合感染和35%全阴性。16S分析确认了细菌qPCR结果并区分AV、BV和乳杆菌主导的微生物组模式。
要点
- 显微镜加Nugent评分与qPCR法总体一致率76%,9例「菌群改变」中5例qPCR判为BV阳性。
- 综合qPCR可识别AV和STI等显微镜未覆盖的病因,支持更全面诊断。
- 16S微生物组分析确认细菌qPCR结果,并区分AV、BV与乳杆菌主导模式。
核心结论
- 综合qPCR联合BV解读算法可提供比显微镜更全面的阴道炎病因诊断,包括AV和STI。
- 16S rRNA微生物组分析确认了细菌qPCR结果,并能区分AV、BV和乳杆菌主导的微生物组模式。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,纳入93名女性(平均年龄23.53岁,范围18至42岁),采集阴道拭子。
- 比较显微镜检查(BV和假丝酵母)与综合定量PCR(含AV、假丝酵母、STI和BV检测及BV解读算法)和16S rRNA基因微生物组谱分析(Illumina)。
主要发现
- 显微镜加BV Nugent评分与qPCR加BV解读算法总体一致率为76%(24例阳性,47例阴性)。
- Nugent判为菌群改变的9例样本中,qPCR法判定5例BV阳性、4例BV阴性;后者中3/4有AV靶标阳性,其中1例同时STI阳性。
- 显微镜鉴定假丝酵母与qPCR的一致率为94%(9例阳性,78例阴性)。
- 综合qPCR显示38% BV、10% AV、5%假丝酵母、2% STI、10%混合感染(多面板靶标阳性)和35%所有靶标阴性。
临床怎么用
- 对于显微镜判为菌群改变但BV阴性的患者,可考虑qPCR检测AV和STI以明确替代病因。
- 综合qPCR可补充显微镜未覆盖的AV和STI检测,帮助指导治疗。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Vaginitis is often diagnosed by microscopy and limited to testing for bacterial vaginosis (BV), vulvovaginal candidiasis, and trichomoniasis. Approximately 10% of vaginal swabs are negative but designated "altered flora" by BV Nugent score, leaving clinicians unsure how to treat patients. Accurate and comprehensive vaginitis diagnostics are needed to direct treatment and reduce risks of recurrent or more severe infections. Vaginal swabs were collected from 93 women (mean age, 23.53 years; range, 18 to 42 years) in a cross-sectional study. Microscopy results for BV and Candida were compared to those from two molecular approaches: (i) a comprehensive quantitative PCR (qPCR) assay, including testing for aerobic vaginitis (AV), Candida, sexually transmitted infections (STI), and BV (Applied Biosystems) with an accompanying BV interpretive algorithm (Coriell Life Sciences), and (ii) microbiome profiling of the 16S rRNA gene (Illumina). Microscopy plus BV Nugent score had 76% overall agreement with the qPCR plus BV interpretive algorithm method (24 positive, 47 negative). OF the nine samples designated altered flora by Nugent, five were categorized BV positive and four were BV negative by the qPCR method. Although BV negative, 3/4 of the latter samples had positive AV targets with one also was STI positive. Microscopic identification of Candida versus that by qPCR had 94% agreement (9 positive, 78 negative). The comprehensive qPCR assay revealed alternative etiologies summarized as 38% BV, 10% AV, 5% Candida, 2% STI, 10% mixed infection (positive targets in multiple panels), and 35% negative for all targets. 16S microbiome analysis confirmed the bacterial qPCR results and identified differentiating patterns between AV, BV, and Lactobacillus-dominated vaginal microbiomes.
引用
- Lynch T, Peirano G, Lloyd T, et al. Molecular Diagnosis of Vaginitis: Comparing Quantitative PCR and Microbiome Profiling Approaches to Current Microscopy Scoring. J Clin Microbiol. 2019. PMID: 31315951. doi:10.1128/JCM.00300-19
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。