HbA1c常规检测的正确度评估:加工EQA材料是否胜任?
研究采用偏倚差异法评估26种加工质控材料在17种常用HbA1c检测方法间的互换性,并在450家医学实验室用新鲜临床标本评估检测正确度。结果显示加工EQA材料互换性高度异质且总体不足,多数材料不适合评估HbA1c检测正确度和方法间一致性,仅能提供精密度和与同行结果可比性信息;新鲜全血标本显示多数HbA1c检测方法相当准确,符合5 mmol/mol总允许误差质量目标。
要点
- 加工EQA材料互换性不足,多数不适合评估HbA1c检测正确度
- 加工EQA材料仅能提供精密度和实验室间可比性信息
- 新鲜全血标本显示多数HbA1c检测方法符合5 mmol/mol总允许误差
核心结论
- 由于互换性不足,大多数加工EQA材料不适合评估HbA1c检测的正确度及方法间一致性。
- 加工EQA材料仅能提供单个实验室结果与同行可比性和检测精密度的信息。
- 使用新鲜全血标本显示多数HbA1c检测方法相当准确,符合5 mmol/mol总允许误差质量目标。
研究设计与样本
- 采用偏倚差异法评估26种加工质控材料对17种最常用HbA1c检测方法的互换性,检测在制造商或专家实验室完成。
- 使用分发至450家医学实验室的新鲜临床标本,对照IFCC参考测量程序评估检测正确度。
主要发现
- 加工EQA材料的互换性高度异质,总体不足以严格评估HbA1c检测的正确度。
- 使用新鲜临床标本,低HbA1c(34 mmol/mol)的平均偏倚为-0.13 mmol/mol。
- 中间HbA1c(49和58 mmol/mol)的平均偏倚在+1.0至+1.3 mmol/mol之间。
- 高HbA1c(90 mmol/mol)的平均偏倚为+1.2 mmol/mol。
临床怎么用
- 检验科应认识到加工EQA材料主要用于评估精密度和实验室间可比性,不能替代正确度评估。
- 评估HbA1c检测正确度时应使用新鲜临床标本或经互换性验证的材料。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Background With the worldwide increase of diabetes mellitus prevalence, ensuring that HbA1c assays are accurate is essential. External quality assessment (EQA) programs enable laboratories to verify that analytical methods perform according to the manufacturers' specifications. However, assessing trueness requires commutable materials, a property that is rarely characterized for EQA materials. Methods The difference in bias approach was used to assess commutability of 26 processed quality control materials for 17 of the most frequently used HbA1c assays. Involved assays included immuno-assays, enzymatic assays, affinity, ion-exchange HPLC boronate affinity HPLC and capillary electrophoresis. The measurements were performed at manufacturers or expert laboratories. Assay trueness was additionally assessed against the IFCC reference measurement procedure using fresh clinical specimens that were distributed to 450 medical laboratories. Results Commutability of processed EQA materials was highly heterogeneous and globally insufficient to rigorously assess the trueness of HbA1c assays. Using fresh clinical specimens, mean bias was -0.13 mmol/mol for low HbA1c (34 mmol/mol), between +1.0 and +1.3 mmol/mol for intermediate HbA1c (49 and 58 mmol/mol) and +1.2 mmol/mol for elevated HbA1c (90 mmol/mol). Conclusions This study demonstrates that due to insufficient commutability, most processed EQA materials are unsuitable to assess trueness of HbA1c assays and agreement between the different assays. These materials can only provide information on comparability of individual laboratory results with its peers and on assay precision. Using fresh whole blood samples, this study additionally shows that most HbA1c assays are fairly accurate and meet the total allowable error quality target of 5 mmol/mol.
引用
- Delatour V, Clouet-Foraison N, Jaisson S, et al. Trueness assessment of HbA1c routine assays: are processed EQA materials up to the job? Clin Chem Lab Med. 2019. PMID: 31085744. doi:10.1515/cclm-2019-0219
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。