USP<71>、BacT/Alert Dual-T与Bactec FX用于产品无菌检测污染物的综合评估
该研究比较了药典USP<71>、Bactec FX和BacT/Alert Dual-T三种系统在检测产品无菌测试污染物中的性能,使用118株代表NIH cGMP环境的挑战菌。结果显示Bactec FX系统性能欠佳,而BacT/Alert在32.5°C结合SDA平板可作为USP<71>的可接受替代方法。
要点
- Bactec FX系统对产品无菌测试污染物的检测性能劣于USP<71>和BacT/Alert。
- BacT/Alert在32.5°C结合补充SDA平板可作为USP<71>的可接受替代。
- 延长培养至360小时并终端目视检查可提高灵敏度。
核心结论
- Bactec FX系统对于产品无菌测试不够理想,BacT/Alert在32.5°C结合SDA平板可作为USP<71>的可接受替代方法。
研究设计与样本
- 研究评估了三种检测系统(药典USP<71>、Bactec FX和BacT/Alert Dual-T)在七种不同培养组合下的性能,使用118株代表NIH cGMP环境的挑战菌。
主要发现
- 在细菌检测<96小时和真菌检测<144小时的时间点,USP<71>方法显著优于Bactec FX系统(84.7% vs 64.4%;P=0.0006),但与32.5°C的BacT/Alert系统无显著差异(78.8%;P=0.3116)。
- 延长培养至360小时并终端目视检查提高了灵敏度,USP<71>与BacT/Alert之间无显著差异(95.7% vs 89.0%;P=0.0860),两者均优于Bactec FX系统(71.2%;P<0.0001和P=0.0003)。
- Bactec FX和BacT/Alert系统对30株来自临床血流感染的分离株表现相当,证实系统针对临床微生物而非环境污染物进行了优化。
- 配对SDA平板在可接受时间范围内对真菌始终阳性。
临床怎么用
- 对于产品无菌测试,可考虑使用BacT/Alert在32.5°C结合补充SDA平板作为USP<71>的替代方法。
- Bactec FX系统不推荐用于产品无菌测试。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The emergence of cell therapy programs in large academic centers has led to an increasing demand for clinical laboratories to assist with product sterility testing. Automated blood culture systems have shown promise as alternatives to the manual USP<71> compendial method, but current published data are limited by small organism test sets, particularly for molds. In 2015, failure of the Bactec FX system to detect mold contamination in two products prompted us to evaluate three test systems (compendial USP<71>, Bactec FX, and BacT/Alert Dual-T) over seven different culture combinations, using 118 challenge organisms representative of the NIH current good manufacturing practice (cGMP) environment. At <96 h and <144 h for bacterial and fungal detection, respectively, the compendial USP<71> method significantly outperformed the Bactec FX system (84.7% versus 64.4%; P = 0.0006) but not the BacT/Alert system at 32.5°C (78.8%; P = 0.3116). Extended incubation to 360 h with terminal visual inspection improved sensitivity, without a significant difference between compendial USP<71> and BacT/Alert testing (95.7% versus 89.0%; P = 0.0860); both systems were better than the Bactec FX system (71.2%; P < 0.0001 and P = 0.0003, respectively). The Bactec FX and BacT/Alert systems performed equivalently for 30 isolates derived from clinical bloodstream infections, confirming system optimization for clinical organisms rather than environmental contaminants. Paired Sabouraud dextrose agar (SDA) plates were always positive for fungi within the acceptable time frame. This study shows that the Bactec FX system is suboptimal for product sterility testing, and it provides strong data to support the use of BacT/Alert testing at 32.5°C paired with a supplemental SDA plate as an acceptable alternative to the compendial USP<71> method for product sterility testing.
引用
- England MR, Stock F, Gebo JET, et al. Comprehensive Evaluation of Compendial USP<71>, BacT/Alert Dual-T, and Bactec FX for Detection of Product Sterility Testing Contaminants. J Clin Microbiol. 2019. PMID: 30541938. doi:10.1128/JCM.01548-18
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。