中国1066家实验室HbA1c测量系统的西格玛度量性能评价
该研究纳入2017年参加全国室间质评并上报HbA1c室内质控数据的1066家实验室,用偏倚和变异系数计算西格玛值并结合Westgard西格玛规则选择质控规则。结果显示56.19%实验室满足偏倚标准、55.63%满足不精密度标准,但80.21%实验室需改进HbA1c检测性能。
要点
- 80.21%(855/1066)的实验室HbA1c检测性能需改进。
- 56.19%满足偏倚标准,55.63%满足不精密度标准。
- TOSOH G7/G8组σ≥3的构成比最高。
核心结论
- 大多数实验室HbA1c分析质量需改进,应关注检测性能。
- 中国EQA组织者应完善评价标准并推动HbA1c标准化。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入2017年参加EQA并上报HbA1c IQC数据的1066家实验室。
- 偏倚与变异系数取自国家临床检验中心设计的EQA和IQC程序。
- 用σ值评估HbA1c性能,并结合Westgard Sigma Rules选择质控规则。
主要发现
- 使用Bia-Rad HPLC、TOSOH G7/G8、ARKRAY HA8160/8180、HUIZHONG MQ-2000/2000PT、Roche、Primus HPLC及其他系统的参与者分别为388、190、185、100、59、55、89家。
- HUIZHONG MQ-2000/2000PT组偏倚变异最小。
- 56.19%(599/1066)实验室满足偏倚标准,55.63%(593/1066)满足不精密度标准。
- 80.21%(855/1066)实验室的西格玛度量提示需改进HbA1c性能。
- TOSOH G7/G8组σ≥3的构成比最高。
关键数值与推荐
- σ≥3为TOSOH G7/G8组构成比最高的西格玛阈值。
- 偏倚标准满足率56.19%(599/1066),不精密度标准满足率55.63%(593/1066)。
临床怎么用
- 实验室可结合σ值与Westgard Sigma Rules为各自HbA1c检测系统选择合适质控规则。
- 应关注HbA1c检测的偏倚与不精密度并持续改进分析质量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: This study aimed to evaluate the performance of HbA1c measurement systems quantitatively with sigma metric and promote the quality improvement. METHODS: 1066 laboratories enrolled external quality assessment (EQA) and reported their internal quality control (IQC) data for HbA1c in 2017 were included in this study. The bias and coefficient of variation were collected from EQA and IQC program designed by the National Center for Clinical Laboratory. The σ values was used to assess the performance of HbA1c, and combine Westgard Sigma Rules™ to select proper quality control rules in every laboratory. RESULTS: Totally, There were 388,190,185,100,59,55,89 participants used Bia-Rad HPLC, TOSOH G7/G8, ARKRAY HA8160/8180, HUIZHONG MQ-2000/2000PT, Roche, Primus HPLC and "Others" system, respectively. "HUIZHONG MQ-2000/2000PT" group had the smallest variation of bias. 56.19% (599/1066) of laboratories met bias criterion and 55.63% (593/1066) satisfied imprecision criterion. However, sigma metrics indicated that 80.21% (855/1066) of 1066 laboratories needed to improve their performance of HbA1c. Moreover, "TOSOH G7/G8" group had the highest constituent ration of σ ≥ 3. CONCLUSIONS: The analytical quality of HbA1c in most laboratories need improving. Laboratories should pay more attention on the performance of HbA1c, and EQA organizers in China should improve evaluation criteria and push standardization work for HbA1c.
引用
- Huang Y, Zhang T, Zhao H, et al. Performance evaluation of HbA1c measurement systems with sigma metric for 1066 laboratories in China. Clin Chim Acta. 2018. PMID: 30312599. doi:10.1016/j.cca.2018.10.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。