质控限是否设置过宽?短期与长期变异估计的比较
该研究通过文献综述、统计理论分析、模拟研究和实验室数据,比较临床实验室科学(CLS)中短期与长期变异估计方法对质控限的影响。研究发现CLS教科书和原始文献极少提及短期变异方法,而其他领域标准质控文本推荐短期变异方法;95张质控图中93张显示两种估计存在显著差异,长期变异估计常大于短期估计,18%的案例中长期与短期变异比值大于1.5。结论提示基于长期变异的质控限可能过宽。
要点
- 临床实验室常用长期变异估计质控限,而其他领域多用短期变异。
- 95张质控图中93张显示短期与长期变异估计存在显著差异。
- 长期变异估计常大于短期估计,18%案例比值大于1.5,质控限可能过宽。
核心结论
- 基于短期和长期变异的估计可导致显著差异,长期变异估计常大于短期变异估计。
研究设计与样本
- 文献综述比较CLS与其他领域的变异估计方法推荐。
- 统计理论分析展示短期与长期估计的理论差异。
- 模拟研究构建短期与长期估计导致质控限显著差异的示例。
- 实验室数据比较短期与长期变异估计,检查95张质控图。
主要发现
- CLS教科书未提及基于短期变异的方法,原始文献仅1篇提及。
- 其他领域标准质控文本推荐短期变异方法,原始文献频繁引用。
- 统计论文显示长期变异估计可产生膨胀的过程变异估计。
- 95张质控图中93张短期与长期变异估计存在显著差异。
- 18%的案例中长期与短期变异比值大于1.5。
临床怎么用
- 临床实验室应考虑采用短期变异估计方法以设置更准确的质控限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Quality control charts (Levey Jennings Charts) are based on estimates of variation. There are two general approaches for estimating variation: those based on short-term variation and those based on long-term variation. We have observed that clinical laboratory science (CLS) tends to estimate variation using long-term variation but that most other fields use short-term variation. The objective of this study is to compare these two methods of estimating process variation, compare the accuracy of control limits generated by each method, and explore whether it would be useful for clinical laboratories to adopt methods used in other fields. METHODS: We conducted a literature review to compare recommendations for methods for estimation of variation in CLS with other fields. We searched textbooks for suggested methods and also searched the primary literature for references to methods associated with short-term and long-term variation. We provide theoretical results from statistics to show that, in theory, short-term estimates can differ from long-term estimates of variation. We used simulation studies to show that one can construct examples where short-term and long-term estimates of variation lead to significant differences in control limits. Finally, we show laboratory data comparing short-term and long-term estimates of variation. RESULTS: We found that practice in CLS differs from other fields. We found no references to methods based on short-term variation in CLS textbooks and only one reference in the primary literature. In contrast, standard quality control (QC) texts recommend methods based on short-term variation and the primary literature makes frequent reference to such methods. We found statistical papers that show that, in theory, estimates based on long-term variation can produce inflated estimates of process variation. We used simulation to show that such examples can be constructed. We examined 95 QC charts and found that in 93 cases, there were significant differences between short-term and long-term estimates of variation. The ratio of long-term to short-term variation was greater than 1.5 in 18% of cases. CONCLUSION: Estimates of variation based on short-term and long-term variation can lead to significant differences in estimates. Estimates based on long-term variation are frequently larger than estimates based on short-term variation.
引用
- Schmidt RL, Walker BS, Pearson LN, et al. Quality control limits: Are we setting them too wide? Clin Chim Acta. 2018. PMID: 30144437. doi:10.1016/j.cca.2018.08.031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。