医学健康检查中传统与反向梅毒筛查算法的比较
该研究对1000份健康体检血标本同时应用传统筛查(RPR)与反向筛查(TPLA),反向算法阳性68份(6.8%),传统算法阳性11份(1.1%)。传统算法漏检48份TPLA(+)/RPR(-)/CMIA(+)标本,反向算法可发现传统算法未检出的可能潜伏梅毒者。初始TPLA的COI值在CMIA反应性与非反应性病例间存在差异。
要点
- 反向筛查算法可检出传统算法漏检的可能潜伏梅毒者。
- 传统算法漏检48份TPLA(+)/RPR(-)/CMIA(+)标本。
- 初始TPLA的COI值或有助于排除反向算法中的假阳性。
核心结论
- 反向筛查算法能检出传统算法未发现的可能潜伏梅毒受检者,为其提供体检中评估梅毒的机会。
- 初始TPLA检测的COI值可能有助于排除反向算法中的TPLA假阳性结果。
研究设计与样本
- 研究共纳入1000份健康体检血标本,来自908名男性和92名女性。
- 对同一批标本分别应用传统筛查(自动RPR)与反向筛查(TPLA)。
- 对反向算法(TPLA)反应性的标本,采用化学发光微粒子免疫分析(CMIA)进行第二种密螺旋体检测。
主要发现
- 1000份标本中,反向筛查(TPLA)反应性68份(6.8%),传统筛查(RPR)反应性11份(1.1%)。
- 传统算法漏检48份TPLA(+)/RPR(-)/CMIA(+)标本。
- CMIA反应性病例的中位TPLA cutoff index(COI)高于CMIA非反应性病例(90.5 vs 12.5 U)。
临床怎么用
- 在健康体检场景中可考虑采用反向梅毒筛查算法以减少可能潜伏梅毒的漏检。
- 反向算法中TPLA反应性标本应加做第二种密螺旋体检测以辅助判读。
- 可结合初始TPLA的COI值辅助排除TPLA假阳性结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The syphilis diagnostic algorithms applied in different countries vary significantly depending on the local syphilis epidemiology and other considerations, including the expected workload, the need for automation in the laboratory and budget factors. This study was performed to investigate the efficacy of traditional and reverse syphilis diagnostic algorithms during general health checkups. METHODS: In total, 1,000 blood specimens were obtained from 908 men and 92 women during their regular health checkups. Traditional screening and reverse screening were applied to the same specimens using automatic rapid plasma regain (RPR) and Treponema pallidum latex agglutination (TPLA) tests, respectively. Specimens that were reverse algorithm (TPLA) reactive, were subjected to a second treponemal test performed by using the chemiluminescent microparticle immunoassay (CMIA). RESULTS: Of the 1,000 specimens tested, 68 (6.8%) were reactive by reverse screening (TPLA) compared with 11 (1.1%) by traditional screening (RPR). The traditional algorithm failed to detect 48 specimens [TPLA(+)/RPR(-)/CMIA(+)]. The median TPLA cutoff index (COI) was higher in CMIA-reactive cases than in CMIA-nonreactive cases (90.5 vs 12.5 U). CONCLUSIONS: The reverse screening algorithm could detect the subjects with possible latent syphilis who were not detected by the traditional algorithm. Those individuals could be provided with opportunities for evaluating syphilis during their health checkups. The COI values of the initial TPLA test may be helpful in excluding false-positive TPLA test results in the reverse algorithm.
引用
- Nah EH, Cho S, Kim S, et al. Comparison of Traditional and Reverse Syphilis Screening Algorithms in Medical Health Checkups. Ann Lab Med. 2017. PMID: 28840989. doi:10.3343/alm.2017.37.6.511
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。