以风险思维强化实验室质量:尼日利亚的实施挑战与机遇
该综述评估尼日利亚实验室质量现状及ISO 15189:2022和CLSI EP23风险思维框架在资源有限环境中的适用性,通过系统检索2010-2025年85个来源(含66项研究),识别实施障碍并提出缓解策略,认为转向风险思维对实现主动韧性至关重要。
要点
- 传统质控偏反应性,未覆盖分析前和分析后阶段的高比例错误。
- 仅26家机构(不足行业0.5%)获认可,多数实验室面临责备文化、人才外流和电力不稳。
- 风险思维框架可量化环境风险,指导太阳能和人员能力等资源精准投入。
核心结论
- 尼日利亚实验室需从反应性合规转向主动韧性,通过风险思维管理电力不稳和供应链波动等风险,以数据驱动优化稀缺资源保障患者安全。
研究设计与样本
- 本综述为综合性叙述性综述,系统检索PubMed、Scopus和AJOL 2010-2025年文献,纳入85个来源(含66项经关键性矩阵筛选的研究),以PDCA框架结合质量指标进行综合分析。
主要发现
- 行业两极分化,精英私立和捐助资助的公立实验室推动认可(仅26家设施,不足行业0.5%),多数实验室受困于责备文化、人才外流综合征和电力不稳。
- Parvin风险管理指数等风险思维框架可量化独特环境风险,支持针对性资源分配。
- EL-LAB和HVL案例及COVID-19经验表明,风险思维通过科学验证太阳能和人员能力投资来增强韧性。
关键数值与推荐
- ISO 15189:2022要求采用风险思维,CLSI EP23提供框架,Parvin风险管理指数可量化环境风险。
- 认可实验室仅26家,占行业不足0.5%。
临床怎么用
- 实验室应采用风险思维框架识别和分析前、分析后及环境风险,优先投资太阳能和人员 competence 以缓解电力不稳和供应链波动。
- 利用风险量化工具指导稀缺资源分配,从责备文化转向数据驱动的主动改进。
局限性
- 本文为叙述性综述,未报告原始研究数据或定量合并结果,结论基于文献综合和案例推断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Medical laboratories in Nigeria are pivotal for national health security but operate under severe infrastructural deficits and a high disease burden. Traditional Quality Control (QC) methods are prevalent but reactive and fail to address the high proportion of errors occurring in pre- and post-analytical phases. This necessitates a strategic shift toward Risk-Based Thinking (RBT) as mandated by the new ISO 15189:2022 standard to bridge the gap between international requirements and local environmental volatility. OBJECTIVES: This review assesses the current state of laboratory quality in Nigeria and evaluates the applicability of RBT frameworks (ISO 15189:2022 and CLSI EP23) in resource-limited settings. It aims to identify structural and cultural implementation barriers and propose actionable mitigation strategies. METHODS: This comprehensive narrative review utilized a systematic search strategy across PubMed, Scopus, and AJOL covering 2010-2025. Data from 85 identified sources, including 66 studies selected using a defined criticality matrix, were synthesized using the Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) framework operationalized with specific quality indicators to contrast regulatory expectations with operational realities. MAIN TEXT: The sector is polarized, with elite private and donor-funded public laboratories driving accreditation (representing only 26 facilities or < 0.5% of the sector), while the majority struggle with a punitive blame culture, the "Japa" syndrome workforce crisis, and erratic power supply. RBT frameworks like Parvin's Risk Management Index offer tools to quantify these unique environmental risks and enable targeted resource allocation. Case studies from EL-LAB and HVL, alongside adaptive lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic, demonstrate that RBT facilitates resilience by scientifically validating investments in solar energy and staff competence to mitigate local hazards. CONCLUSION: Transitioning to RBT is critical for Nigerian laboratories to move from reactive compliance to proactive resilience. By managing risks like power instability and supply chain volatility, laboratories can effectively optimize scarce resources through data-driven mitigation to ensure patient safety.
引用
- Basil B, Eze OE. Strengthening laboratory quality through risk-based thinking: Implementation challenges and opportunities in Nigeria. Clin Chim Acta. 2026. PMID: 42081931. doi:10.1016/j.cca.2026.121041
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。