LC-MS/MS与免疫法测定儿童血清1,25-二羟维生素D的一致性不一致
该研究比较了DiaSorin LIAISON® XL免疫法与LC-MS/MS测定血清1,25(OH)2D3/D2的一致性。成人样本n=80(平均21.7岁)相关性好(r2=0.9331),但儿童样本n=422(平均7.3岁)相关性弱(r2=0.6536),偏倚更大(-9.8 pmol/L),提示儿童中维生素D代谢物影响测定,需改进方法协调和儿童参考区间。
要点
- 成人样本两法相关性强(r2=0.9331),儿童样本相关性弱(r2=0.6536)。
- 儿童样本LC-MS/MS较DiaSorin平均偏低9.8 pmol/L,偏倚大于成人。
- 儿童中维生素D代谢物可能干扰免疫法测定,需建立LC-MS/MS儿童参考区间。
核心结论
- 儿童样本中免疫法与LC-MS/MS测定1,25(OH)2D的一致性不一致,可能与维生素D代谢物有关。
- 需改进方法协调并建立基于LC-MS/MS的儿童参考区间。
研究设计与样本
- 研究比较DiaSorin LIAISON® XL免疫法与LC-MS/MS(免疫亲和富集和DAPTAD衍生化)测定血清1,25(OH)2D3/D2。
- 样本包括健康年轻成人n=80(平均年龄21.7岁,范围18-32岁)和儿童n=422(平均年龄7.3岁,范围0-17岁)。
主要发现
- 两种方法批内/批间不精密度均≤9.4%。
- DEQAS(2020年4月至2024年1月,n=80)显示DiaSorin平均偏倚-0.6%(SD 6.2,95%CI -12.8至11.6),LC-MS/MS +1.3%(SD 7.4,95%CI -13.3至15.8)。
- 成人样本两法强相关(r2=0.9331)和一致性(CCC=0.959),LC-MS/MS较DiaSorin平均低-1.6 pmol/L(SD 14.3,95%CI -29.6至26.5),高浓度负偏倚增加。
- 儿童样本相关性较弱(r2=0.6536)和一致性(CCC=0.782),偏倚更大:平均-9.8 pmol/L(SD 23.4,95%CI -55.7至35.9)。
- 儿童样本变异性与浓度或年龄无关;纳入1,25(OH)2D2后相关性和一致性提高。
临床怎么用
- 临床解读儿童1,25(OH)2D免疫法结果时需谨慎,尤其与LC-MS/MS结果不一致时。
- 儿童维生素D评估可能需要LC-MS/MS方法及配套参考区间。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Automated immunoassays for 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D (1,25(OH)2D) have increased the use of serum measurements in clinical and research settings, but disagreement with LC-MS/MS methods remains an issue. METHODS: In this study, we examined this problem using samples obtained from healthy young adults, n=80, mean age 21.7 (18-32) years, and a large cohort of paediatric samples, n=422, mean age 7.3 (0-17) years. We compared serum concentrations of 1,25(OH)2D3/D2 produced by the DiaSorin LIAISON® XL immunoassay against an LC-MS/MS method with immunoaffinity enrichment and DAPTAD derivation. RESULTS: Both assays showed intra/inter-assay imprecision of ≤9.4 % across their respective assay range. DEQAS between April 2020 to Jan 2024 (n=80) showed mean bias (SD, 95 %CI) for DiaSorin -0.6 % (6.2, -12.8 to 11.6) and LC-MS/MS of +1.3 % (7.4, -13.3 to 15.8) against their respective method group means. Comparison of measurements in the adult samples showed a strong correlation (r2=0.9331) and concordance (CCC=0.959) between the two methods. LC-MS/MS values were lower than DiaSorin by an overall mean (±SD, 95 %CI) of -1.6 (±14.3, -29.6 to 26.5) pmol/L with an increased negative bias at higher concentrations. In the paediatric samples, weaker correlation (r2=0.6536) and concordance (CCC=0.782) were observed, with greater bias mean (±SD, 95 %CI) of -9.8 (±23.4, -55.7 to 35.9) pmol/L. The variability in the paediatric samples was not associated with concentration or participant age. There was an increase in the correlation and concordance when 1,25(OH)2D2 was included in the analysis. CONCLUSIONS: It is likely that the metabolites of vitamin D present in the paediatric population contributed to the measurement of 1,25(OH)2D. The inconsistent agreement highlights the need for better assay harmonisation and paediatric reference intervals using LC-MS/MS method.
引用
- Tang JCY, Dunn R, Dutton JJ, et al. Measurement of 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D in serum by LC-MS/MS compared to immunoassay reveals inconsistent agreement in paediatric samples. Clin Chem Lab Med. 2024. PMID: 39648164. doi:10.1515/cclm-2024-1032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。