超越基础:可变总允许误差下的检验医学西格玛评分
该研究使用20项常规生化参数,基于12个月室内质控CV和室间质评偏倚,采用六种总允许误差来源计算西格玛评分。结果显示不同TEa来源下西格玛值差异显著,RCPA和生物学变异最严格,RiliBak最宽松,强调需统一TEa标准。
要点
- 不同TEa来源导致西格玛评分显著差异,影响质控规则选择。
- RCPA和生物学变异标准最严格,多数参数低于3西格玛。
- RiliBak和CLIA'88较宽松,仅少数参数低于3西格玛。
核心结论
- 不同总允许误差来源对西格玛评分评估有显著影响,需统一和标准化西格玛指标并选择合适的TEa目标。
研究设计与样本
- 使用Beckman Coulter AU680分析仪,基于12个月室内质控CV和室间质评偏倚,对20项常规生化参数计算西格玛评分。
- 采用六种TEa来源:CLIA'88、CLIA 24、BDV、RCPA、RiliBak、EMC/Spain。
主要发现
- 西格玛值随TEa来源不同而显著变化。
- CLIA'88下TBil、HDL、CK、ALP、淀粉酶和尿酸多数参数在3西格玛以上。
- RCPA和生物学变异最严格,性能最高的参数也低于3西格玛。
- RiliBak最宽松,仅钠低于3西格玛,与CLIA'88类似。
关键数值与推荐
- 西格玛计算公式:Sigma = (TEa - Bias%) / CV%。
- 使用Bio-Rad Unity 2.0软件(Westgard西格玛多规则)制定质控计划。
临床怎么用
- 根据西格玛评分选择适当质控规则,对低西格玛参数采取加强电极清洗、更换电极、试剂管理、仪器维护等措施。
局限性
- TEa目标缺乏共识,不同来源TEa值可能变化,影响西格玛评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: To diagnose diseases, track the effectiveness of treatments and make well-informed clinical decisions, doctors rely on results from laboratories. Accurate and precise results minimize the necessity for additional testing, saving time and money while enhancing patient satisfaction.. Internal quality control and an external quality assurance scheme(EQAS) are metrics used to evaluate a clinical laboratory's performance. One of the numerous quality indicators that can be used to gauge the amount of errors is sigma metrics. To calculate the sigma scores bias%, CV%, and Total Error Allowable (TEa) are needed. Total Error allowable(TEa) is a crucial benchmark that establishes allowed limits on the degree of deviation from the target value for a certain analyte. Nevertheless, a proper consensus for establishing a TEa goal has not been reached and the impact of this limiting factor in standard laboratory practice and sigma calculation has not been sufficiently established. Choosing the right Total Error allowable(TEa) goal is one of the greatest challenges when employing sigma metrics as depending on the source, several measurands of TEa values may exhibit alteration. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Our study aims to determine the sigma scores of 20 routine chemistry parameters using six different TEa sources: Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendment (CLIA 88'), CLIA(Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendment) 24, BDV (Biological Variation Desirable), RCPA(Royal College of Pathologists of Australasia), RiliBak(Guideline of the German Medical Association for Quality Assurance of Laboratory Medical Examinations), and EMC/Spain(Measurement and Control Scheme) over a 12-month period using the bias percent from the External Quality Assessment Scheme (EQAS) and coefficient of variation (CV) from the Internal Quality Control (IQC). Detection system was automated, multi-channel, selective analyzer, the Beckman Coulter AU680 which works on the principle of spectrophotometry. To compute the Sigma metrics, formula used was Sigma = (TEa - Bias%) / CV%. By comparing the sigma values from the different TEa sources, TEa variance on the evaluation of the sigma metric was ascertained after which an internal quality control plan and QGI(Quality Goal Index) for underperforming parameters were devised. RESULTS: The study discovered that the sigma values of common chemical parameters varied significantly based on the TEa sources used. Maximum parameters in the above three-sigma zone were TBil, HDL, CK, ALP, amylase and uric acid in CLIA'88 while RCPA and Biological variation were determined to be the most severe, with the highest performing parameters falling below three sigma zones. Rilibaek was the most liberal, with only sodium in the lower three sigma zones along with CLIA'88. The findings indicate that there is the substantial influence of various Total Error Allowable (TEa) sources on the sigma metric evaluation. A quality control plan was devised depending on different sigma scores of the analytes using biorad unity 2.0 software(westgard sigma multirules). The origins of errors that resulted in low sigma ratings liked enhanced cleaning of electrodes, electrode replacement, ageing of reagents, instrument maintainence were pinpointed and addressed. CONCLUSION: The study highlights the necessity of harmonizing and standardizing sigma metrics, stressing the significance of choosing suitable total error allowable goals (TEa). The creation of worldwide standards and recommendations for total error allowable (TEa) can lead to its harmonization. Establishing a consensus on the acceptable levels of error for various laboratory tests would necessitate the cooperation of specialists from many nations and organizations in order to set such guidelines and standards.
引用
- Yadav D, Rathore M, Banerjee M, et al. Beyond the basics: Sigma scores in laboratory medicine with variable total allowable errors (TEa). Clin Chim Acta. 2024. PMID: 39326693. doi:10.1016/j.cca.2024.119971
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。