伤口拭子培养的例外报告法对报告后启动抗生素的影响
该研究评估伤口拭子培养「例外报告」方案对报告后抗生素启动的影响。例外报告组报告后5天内启动抗生素比例为25.1%,显著低于变更前的49.5%(P < 0.01),且30天内住院或重复采样未见增加。
要点
- 例外报告法可显著降低伤口拭子培养阳性后抗生素启动比例。
- 该策略未增加30天内住院或重复伤口拭子采样。
- 报告中标明菌种可能驱动不必要的抗生素处方。
核心结论
- 例外报告法与伤口拭子培养后抗生素启动比例显著降低相关,且未检测到30天内住院或重复采样增加。
研究设计与样本
- 变更前期间有1,819例、变更后期间有764例样本采取「检测等待」策略且分离出符合例外报告标准的菌株。
主要发现
- 变更后期间407例(53.3%)符合标准并采用例外报告。
- 报告后抗生素启动在变更前为901例(49.5%),例外报告组为102例(25.1%,P < 0.01)。
- 例外报告后30天内住院或重复伤口拭子采样未见可检测的增加。
关键数值与推荐
- 例外报告方案于2023年3月1日引入,对推荐经验治疗(氟氯西林/头孢氨苄)敏感的典型伤口病原体不报告,并提供评论说明未检测到显著耐药菌。
- 完整结果可应临床医生要求提供;不符合方案标准的培养按标准方式报告。
- 「检测等待」定义为报告前未治疗而采样;报告后5天内启动抗生素定义为报告后抗生素启动。
临床怎么用
- 临床微生物实验室可考虑对符合标准的伤口拭子培养采用例外报告法,以减少不必要的抗生素启动。
- 临床医生可应要求获取完整培养结果,以支持个体化决策。
局限性
- 结果需要在其他辖区确认。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: A prior analysis suggested that wound swab culture (WSC) results were driving unnecessary antibiotic use in patients who were not already receiving treatment. As a quality-improvement initiative, our laboratory introduced an "exception-reporting" protocol on 1 March 2023, whereby typical wound pathogens susceptible to recommended empiric therapy (flucloxacillin/cefalexin) were not reported, and a comment was provided, stating no significant resistant organisms had been detected. Full results were available to clinicians on request. Cultures falling outside protocol criteria were reported in the standard fashion. This analysis sought to assess the effect of exception-reporting on post-report antibiotic initiation (PRAI). All community WSC results were matched to antibiotic dispensing records from October 2021 to December 2023. Sampling without treatment pre-report was termed "test and wait" (TaW). Following TaW, PRAI was identified if antibiotics were started within 5 days post-report. There were 1,819 and 764 WSCs received in the pre-change and post-change periods, respectively, where an initial TaW approach had been taken and an organism eligible for exception-reporting had been isolated. In the post-change period, 407 (53.3%) met the criteria and were exception-reported. PRAI occurred in 901 (49.5%) pre-change samples, compared to 102 (25.1%, P < 0.01) with exception-reporting. There was no detectable increase in hospitalization or repeat WSC collection in the 30 days following exception-reporting. Exception-reporting was associated with a markedly reduced proportion of patients being initiated on antibiotics following WSC where an organism had been isolated. The naming of organisms in reports appears to drive unnecessary antibiotic prescribing in many patients. These results require confirmation in other jurisdictions. IMPORTANCE: Wound swab culture is a high-volume test performed in clinical microbiology laboratories. In this analysis, we have shown that an alternative approach to reporting positive wound swab cultures has resulted in a large reduction in post-report antibiotic initiation, suggesting that the current standard method of reporting generates considerable unnecessary antibiotic use. If these findings are replicated elsewhere, wider adoption of this reporting would represent an opportunity for many clinical microbiology laboratories to have a significant impact on community antimicrobial stewardship.
引用
- Bloomfield M, van der Werff K, Todd S, et al. An exception-reporting approach for wound swab culture: effect on post-report antibiotic initiation. J Clin Microbiol. 2024. PMID: 38785447. doi:10.1128/jcm.00342-24
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。