三种血流感染快速诊断试验的获益-风险评估框架比较
该研究基于马里兰大学医学中心301份阳性血培养,采用获益-风险评估框架(BED-FRAME)比较FLAT MS、Bruker Sepsityper和BioFire FilmArray BCID2三种快速诊断试验。三种方法对单微生物阳性血培养总体敏感性为88.3%,但鉴定革兰阳性菌、革兰阴性菌和酵母菌的准确性存在差异;结果时间均约1小时,手工操作时间分别为10、40和5分钟。BED-FRAME显示各方法在不同病原体流行率和相对重要性下各有适用价值。
要点
- FLAT MS、Sepsityper和BCID2结果时间均约1小时。
- 手工操作时间分别为FLAT MS 10分钟、Sepsityper 40分钟、BCID2 5分钟。
- 三种方法对单微生物阳性血培养总体敏感性为88.3%。
核心结论
- BED-FRAME分析表明三种快速诊断试验在不同病原体流行率和相对重要性下各有适用价值。
- BED-FRAME是帮助医疗机构选择最适合本中心快速诊断试验的有用工具。
研究设计与样本
- 研究收集马里兰大学医学中心301份阳性血培养,比较FLAT MS、Bruker Sepsityper和bioMérieux BioFire FilmArray BCID2。
- 采用敏感性、结果时间、手工操作时间和BED-FRAME分析对三种快速诊断试验进行比较。
主要发现
- 所有平台对单微生物阳性血培养的总体敏感性为88.3%。
- 三种快速诊断试验鉴定革兰阳性菌、革兰阴性菌和酵母菌的准确性存在差异。
- FLAT MS、Sepsityper和BioFire BCID2的结果时间均约1小时。
- 手工操作时间分别为FLAT MS 10(±1.3)分钟、Sepsityper 40(±2.8)分钟、BioFire BCID2 5(±0.25)分钟。
关键数值与推荐
- 总体敏感性88.3%为三种平台对单微生物阳性血培养与培养结果比较的合并敏感性。
- FLAT MS手工操作时间10(±1.3)分钟,Sepsityper 40(±2.8)分钟,BioFire BCID2 5(±0.25)分钟。
- 三种快速诊断试验结果时间均约1小时。
临床怎么用
- 临床实验室可借助BED-FRAME框架,结合本中心病原体流行率和相对重要性选择最合适的血流感染快速诊断试验。
- 选择快速诊断试验时需综合考虑敏感性、结果时间、手工操作时间及不同病原体类别的鉴定准确性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) for bloodstream infections have the potential to reduce time to appropriate antimicrobial therapy and improve patient outcomes. Previously, an in-house, lipid-based, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) method, Fast Lipid Analysis Technique (FLAT MS), has shown promise as a rapid pathogen identification method. In this study, FLAT MS for direct from blood culture identification was evaluated and compared to FDA-cleared identification methods using the Benefit-risk Evaluation Framework (BED-FRAME) analysis. FLAT MS was evaluated and compared to Bruker Sepsityper and bioMérieux BioFire FilmArray BCID2 using results from a previous study. For this study, 301 positive blood cultures were collected from the University of Maryland Medical Center. The RDTs were compared by their sensitivities, time-to-results, hands-on time, and BED-FRAME analysis. The overall sensitivity of all platforms compared to culture results from monomicrobial-positive blood cultures was 88.3%. However, the three RDTs differed in their accuracy for identifying Gram-positive bacteria, Gram-negative bacteria, and yeast. Time-to-results for FLAT MS, Sepsityper, and BioFire BCID2 were all approximately one hour. Hands-on times for FLAT MS, Sepsityper, and BioFire BCID2 were 10 (±1.3), 40 (±2.8), and 5 (±0.25) minutes, respectively. BED-FRAME demonstrated that each RDT had utility at different pathogen prevalence and relative importance. BED-FRAME is a useful tool that can used to determine which RDT is best for a healthcare center.
引用
- Smith RD, Zhan M, Zhang S, et al. Comparison of three rapid diagnostic tests for bloodstream infections using Benefit-risk Evaluation Framework (BED-FRAME). J Clin Microbiol. 2023. PMID: 38054730. doi:10.1128/jcm.01096-23
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。