TSH受体抗体浓度的稳定性及其免疫测定法的可比性
本研究利用KRYPTOR法测定过TRAb的剩余血清样本,评估-20°C保存四至六年及最多五次冻融循环后的稳定性,并对436份样本用Alinity与Cobas免疫测定法复测,按cut-off值判定阳性/阴性后比较结果。TRAb结果在五年内及五次冻融循环内保持稳定;三种免疫测定法间86.2%的结果一致,总不一致率分别为Cobas对Alinity 5.4%、Alinity对KRYPTOR 8.8%、Cobas对KRYPTOR 13.3%,KRYPTOR的阴性结果多于Cobas和Alinity。
要点
- TRAb在-20°C保存五年内及最多五次冻融循环后结果稳定。
- 三种免疫测定法间86.2%的结果一致,但总不一致率因方法配对而异。
- KRYPTOR免疫测定法的TRAb阴性结果多于Cobas和Alinity。
核心结论
- Alinity免疫测定法测得的TRAb结果与KRYPTOR和Cobas具有可比性,但较KRYPTOR阳性结果略多、较Cobas阴性结果略多。
研究设计与样本
- 使用已用KRYPTOR测定过TRAb浓度的剩余血清样本;先评估-20°C保存四至六年及最多五次冻融循环的稳定性,再用Alinity和Cobas免疫测定法复测436份样本并按cut-off值判读阳性/阴性进行比较。
主要发现
- TRAb结果在五年内及最多五次冻融循环后保持稳定。
- 三种免疫测定法间86.2%的结果一致。
- 总不一致率为Cobas对Alinity 5.4%、Alinity对KRYPTOR 8.8%、Cobas对KRYPTOR 13.3%。
- KRYPTOR免疫测定法的TRAb阴性结果多于Cobas和Alinity。
- Alinity较KRYPTOR阳性结果略多,较Cobas阴性结果略多。
关键数值与推荐
- TRAb浓度高于预设cut-off值时提示Graves病。
- Alinity与Cobas比较总不一致率为5.4%。
- Alinity与KRYPTOR比较总不一致率为8.8%。
- Cobas与KRYPTOR比较总不一致率为13.3%。
临床怎么用
- TRAb样本可在-20°C保存五年内及最多五次冻融循环后测定。
- 不同TRAb免疫测定法结果不完全一致,解读时应结合所用方法的cut-off值。
- 更换TRAb检测平台时需注意KRYPTOR倾向阴性、Alinity介于两者之间的差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Graves' Disease (GD) is an autoimmune form of hyperthyroidism where autoantibodies are directed against the TSH-receptor (TSH-receptor antibodies; TRAb). GD is suspected if TRAb concentrations are above a pre-specified cut-off value. TRAb concentrations are measured using immunoassays. This study aimed to compare the performance of the recently implemented Alinity immunoassay to the KRYPTOR and Cobas TRAb immunoassays. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Left-over serum samples in which TRAb concentrations were measured (KRYPTOR) were used. First, TRAb stability at -20 °C for four to six years and up to five freeze-thaw cycles were assessed. Second, TRAb measurements (n = 436) were repeated using the Alinity and Cobas immunoassay and results (scored as positive/negative based on cut-off value) were compared. RESULTS: TRAb results were stable over five years and up to five freeze-thaw cycles. When comparing immunoassays, 86.2% of the results were similar. Total discrepancy differed between the immunoassays (5.4% Cobas vs Alinity, 8.8% Alinity vs KRYPTOR, 13.3 % Cobas vs KRYPTOR). The KRYPTOR immunoassay showed more negative TRAb results than Cobas and Alinity. CONCLUSION: The Alinity immunoassay showed comparable TRAb results, even though slightly more positive results compared to the KRYPTORand slightly more negative results compared to the Cobas immunoassay were seen.
引用
- Jansen HI, Gohy HG, Boelen A, et al. Stability of TSH receptor antibody concentrations and comparability of its immunoassays. Clin Chim Acta. 2023. PMID: 37543354. doi:10.1016/j.cca.2023.117505
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。