VITEK MS PRIME 与 MALDI Biotyper Microflex LT 微生物鉴定性能比较
该研究比较了新型 MALDI-TOF 质谱 VITEK MS PRIME(VMS-P)与常规使用的 MALDI Biotyper Microflex LT(MBT)对细菌和酵母的鉴定性能。两系统日常表现相似,VMS-P 重复性更高、置信度评分更好,微菌落鉴定能力更有前景。
要点
- 参考菌株重复性:VMS-P 正确鉴定率 98.4%,高于 MBT 的 94.0%(P<0.01)。
- 常规分离株种鉴定率两系统相似:MBT 90.0% 对 VMS-P 91.4%(P=0.26)。
- 阳性血培养微菌落鉴定率 VMS-P 70.2%,高于 MBT 55.5%(P=0.01)。
核心结论
- MBT 与 VMS-P 在日常常规实践中性能相似,VMS-P 重复性高、置信度评分更好,且微菌落鉴定能力有前景。
研究设计与样本
- 研究比较 VITEK MS PRIME(VMS-P)与 MALDI Biotyper Microflex LT(MBT)两套 MALDI-TOF 质谱系统的鉴定性能。
- 对常规工作流程中的细菌和酵母分离株用两系统处理。
- 阳性血培养瓶经 4 小时琼脂亚培养后,不提取直接鉴定微菌落。
主要发现
- 基于参考菌株的重复性:MBT 处理 1,190 个点,VMS-P 处理 1,190 个点。
- 参考菌株正确鉴定率:MBT 94.0%,VMS-P 98.4%(P<0.01)。
- 参考菌株高置信度鉴定比例:MBT 83.0%,VMS-P 100.0%。
- 常规分离株 1,214 个点种鉴定率:MBT 90.0%,VMS-P 91.4%(P=0.26)。
- 常规分离株高置信度评分比例:MBT 69.8%,VMS-P 87.4%。
临床怎么用
- VMS-P 可用于常规细菌和酵母鉴定,性能与 MBT 相似,且高置信度结果比例更高。
- 对阳性血培养微菌落,VMS-P 直接鉴定成功率更高,有助于缩短报告时间。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) is the cornerstone of bacterial identification. The performance of a new MALDI time-of-flight mass spectrometry VITEK MS PRIME (VMS-P) system was compared with that of the MALDI Biotyper Microflex LT (MBT) system, which is routinely used in our laboratory. METHODS: Sixteen bacterial and yeast reference strains cultured in 20 different media were analyzed over 10 consecutive rounds using both systems. Bacterial and yeast isolates from the routine workflow were processed using both systems. Microcolonies were identified after a 4-hour agar subculture from positive blood culture bottles, without extraction. RESULTS: To determine the repeatability based on the reference strains, 1,190 spots were processed using each system. Correct identification was achieved for 94.0% (MBT) and 98.4% (VMS-P; P<0.01) of spots. Among these, 83.0% (MBT) and 100.0% (VMS-P) were identified with a high degree of confidence. For 1,214 spots from routine isolates, species identification was achieved for 90.0% (MBT) and 91.4% (VMS-P; P=0.26) of spots. For 69.8% (MBT) and 87.4% (VMS-P) of the spots, identification was achieved with a high degree-of-confidence score. When identification was performed using both systems, the agreement between them was 97.9%. The identification of microcolonies from positive blood culture bottles was achieved for 55.5% (MBT) and 70.2% (VMS-P; P=0.01) of spots. CONCLUSIONS: The MBT and VMS-P systems perform similarly in routine daily practice. The new VMS-P system shows high repeatability, better confidence scores for identification, and promising ability to identify microcolonies.
引用
- Grohs P, Remaud E, Lath C, et al. Comparison of the New VITEK MS PRIME System with the Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption Ionization Biotyper Microflex LT for the Identification of Microorganisms. Ann Lab Med. 2023. PMID: 37387490. doi:10.3343/alm.2023.43.6.574
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。