文献速递临床微生物临床免疫

九种市售伤寒即时检验的多中心诊断准确性比较

Comparative Analysis of Commercially Available Typhoid Point-of-Care Tests: Results of a Prospective and Hybrid Retrospective Multicenter Diagnostic Accuracy Study in Kenya and Pakistan.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Microbiol · 2022-11-30

在肯尼亚和巴基斯坦开展前瞻性与回顾性多中心诊断准确性研究,以血培养为参考标准评估九种市售伤寒RDT,共531份血清样本(264份血培养阳性、267份阴性)。各RDT敏感性差异大(0至78.8%),Enterocheck WB整体表现最佳(敏感性72.7%、特异性86.5%),但所有RDT的敏感性和特异性均低于准确诊断所需水平。

要点

  • 九种市售伤寒RDT敏感性范围0至78.8%,整体准确性不足。
  • Enterocheck WB表现最佳:敏感性72.7%、特异性86.5%。
  • 不同流行区之间RDT表现差异极小,亟需更准确的伤寒检测。

核心结论

  • 所有评估的市售伤寒RDT敏感性和特异性均低于推荐用于准确诊断所需水平。
  • 不同流行区之间RDT表现差异极小,凸显对新检测方法的需求。

研究设计与样本

  • 在巴基斯坦和肯尼亚开展前瞻性与回顾性多中心诊断准确性研究(NCT04801602)。
  • 以血培养为参考标准,评估九种市售伤寒RDT(包括Widal试验),共531份血清样本(264份血培养阳性、267份阴性)。
  • 采用Wilson法计算敏感性和特异性的点估计,并用R进行潜在类别分析以处理不完美金标准。

主要发现

  • RDT敏感性范围0至78.8%,差异广泛。
  • Enterocheck WB整体表现最佳:敏感性72.7%、特异性86.5%。
  • 潜在类别模型中,CTK IgG敏感性最高(79.1%),Enterocheck整体准确性最高(敏感性73.8%、特异性94.5%)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 血培养阳性264份、阴性267份,共531份血清样本。
  • Enterocheck WB:敏感性72.7%、特异性86.5%。
  • CTK IgG潜在类别模型敏感性79.1%;Enterocheck潜在类别模型敏感性73.8%、特异性94.5%。

临床怎么用

  • 现有市售伤寒RDT不宜单独用于伤寒的准确诊断。
  • 在流行区使用RDT时应结合临床和血培养等参考标准综合判断。

局限性

  • 血培养作为参考标准并不完美,研究采用潜在类别分析加以处理。
  • 原文未报告其他局限性信息。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Blood and bone marrow cultures are considered the gold standard for the diagnosis of typhoid, but these methods require infrastructure and skilled staff that are not always available in low- and middle-income countries where typhoid is endemic. The objective of the study is to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of nine commercially available Salmonella Typhi rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) using blood culture as a reference standard in a multicenter study. This was a prospective and retrospective multicenter diagnostic accuracy study conducted in two geographically distant areas where typhoid is endemic (Pakistan and Kenya; NCT04801602). Nine RDTs were evaluated, including the Widal test. Point estimates for sensitivity and specificity were calculated using the Wilson method. Latent class analyses were performed using R to address the imperfect gold standard. A total of 531 serum samples were evaluated (264 blood culture positive; 267 blood culture negative). The sensitivity of RDTs varied widely (range, 0 to 78.8%), with the best overall performance shown by Enterocheck WB (72.7% sensitivity, 86.5% specificity). In latent class modeling, CTK IgG was found to have the highest sensitivity (79.1%), while the highest overall accuracy was observed with Enterocheck (73.8% sensitivity, 94.5% specificity). All commercially available Salmonella Typhi RDTs evaluated in the study had sensitivity and specificity values that fell below the required levels to be recommended for an accurate diagnosis. There were minimal differences in RDT performances between regions of endemicity. These findings highlight the clear need for new and more-accurate Salmonella Typhi tests.

来源:J Clin Microbiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sapkota J, Hasan R, Onsare R, et al. Comparative Analysis of Commercially Available Typhoid Point-of-Care Tests: Results of a Prospective and Hybrid Retrospective Multicenter Diagnostic Accuracy Study in Kenya and Pakistan. J Clin Microbiol. 2022. PMID: 36448816. doi:10.1128/jcm.01000-22

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。