替代实验室报告格式的效率、效能与主观用户满意度研究
该研究由EFLM分析后阶段工作组开展,对46名医师、护士和医学生测试了累积报告(迷你图格式)和单次报告(改进表格和z-log格式)与经典表格格式相比的效率、效能和用户满意度。结果显示效能在各格式间无显著差异,迷你图累积格式提高了效率,多数参与者认为替代报告更具吸引力。
要点
- 迷你图累积格式能更快检测报告一般信息且正确率相同
- 改进表格格式效率有边缘显著改善,z-log格式非劣效
- 单次报告可从基本信息设计改进中获益
核心结论
- 图形化累积报告可更快检测报告一般信息且正确性不变
- 替代单次报告格式效能非劣效且主观更具吸引力
研究设计与样本
- 在46名医师、护士和医学生中比较替代报告格式与经典表格格式
- 通过标准化问题评估报告一般项目及疑似诊断和随访治疗或诊断
主要发现
- 效能在新格式和经典格式中均保持很高水平,各组间无显著差异
- 使用迷你图累积格式时所有组效率提高,改进表格格式效率边缘改善
- 回答医学问题时,各报告格式和组间效率与效能相似
- 大多数参与者主观认为所有替代报告更具吸引力
临床怎么用
- 可考虑采用图形化累积报告以加快一般信息检测
- 单次报告可借鉴基本信息设计改进以提升效率
局限性
- 经典单次报告格式存在熟悉度偏倚
- 改进表格格式的效率改善仅为边缘显著
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Although laboratory result presentation may lead to information overload and subsequent missed or delayed diagnosis, little has been done in the past to improve this post-analytical issue. We aimed to investigate the efficiency, efficacy and user satisfaction of alternative report formats. METHODS: We redesigned cumulative (sparkline format) and single reports (improved tabular and z-log format) and tested these on 46 physicians, nurses and medical students in comparison to the classical tabular formats, by asking standardized questions on general items on the reports as well as on suspected diagnosis and follow-up treatment or diagnostics. RESULTS: Efficacy remained at a very high level both in the new formats as well as in the classical formats. We found no significant difference in any of the groups. Efficiency improved in all groups when using the sparkline cumulative format and marginally when showing the improved tabular format. When asking medical questions, efficiency and efficacy remained similar between report formats and groups. All alternative reports were subjectively more attractive to the majority of participants. CONCLUSIONS: Showing cumulative reports as a graphical display led to faster detection of general information on the report with the same level of correctness. Considering the familiarity bias of the classical single report formats, the borderline-significant improvement of the alternative tabular format and the non-inferiority of the z-log format, suggests that single reports might benefit from some improvements derived from basic information design.
引用
- Cadamuro J, Winzer J, Perkhofer L, et al. Efficiency, efficacy and subjective user satisfaction of alternative laboratory report formats. An investigation on behalf of the Working Group for Postanalytical Phase (WG-POST), of the European Federation of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine (EFLM). Clin Chem Lab Med. 2022. PMID: 35696446. doi:10.1515/cclm-2022-0269
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。