评估抗菌药物耐药性综合监测:三种评估工具的使用经验
该研究比较了FAO的AMR-PMP、EU COST Action的NEOH和FP7-EU项目的SURVTOOLS三种评估工具,分析其内容、所需评估过程(含利益相关方参与和资源需求)、跨部门整合覆盖面和适用性。三种工具均涉及多个决策层级和利益相关方参与,但侧重点不同,使用均需兽医流行病学专业知识和不同程度的评估方法培训。
要点
- AMR-PMP侧重意识、证据、治理和实践四个领域,评估者需求较低但需多利益相关方参与。
- NEOH侧重系统特征、学习、共享、领导和基础设施,需描述AMR发展的底层系统。
- SURVTOOL提供评估监测项目有效性、过程和全面性的信息与参考。
核心结论
- 三种工具在不同程度上覆盖AMR监测和One Health方面,选择工具时需考虑评估目的和资源。
研究设计与样本
- 对三种评估工具(AMR-PMP、NEOH、SURVTOOLS)进行内容、评估过程、整合覆盖面和适用性评估,采用预定义评分方案和类似SWOT格式比较。
主要发现
- 所有三种工具均涉及多个决策层级和利益相关方参与方面。
- NEOH关注系统特征、学习、共享、领导和基础设施,需描述AMR发展的底层系统。
- AMR-PMP关注意识、证据、治理和实践四个领域,评估预先选择方面的实施程度。
- SURVTOOL提供评估监测项目有效性、过程和全面性的信息与参考。
- 所有三种工具均需兽医流行病学专业知识和不同程度的评估方法培训。
临床怎么用
- 选择工具时应考虑评估目的、所需利益相关方参与程度和资源需求。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Integrated antimicrobial resistance (AMR) surveillance programmes require regular evaluation to ensure they are fit for purpose and that all actors understand their responsibilities. This will strengthen their relevance for the clinical setting, which depends heavily on continued access to effective treatment options. Several evaluation tools addressing different surveillance aspects are available. OBJECTIVES: The aim was to understand the strengths and weaknesses of three evaluation tools, and to improve guidance on how to choose a fit-for-purpose tool. SOURCES: Three tools were assessed: (a) AMR-PMP-the Progressive Management Pathway tool on AMR developed by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations, (b) NEOH developed by the EU COST Action 'Network for Evaluation of One Health' and (c) SURVTOOLS developed in an FP7-EU project 'RISKSUR'. Each tool was assessed with regard to contents, required evaluation processes including stakeholder engagement and resource demands, integration coverage across relevant sectors and applicability. They were compared using a predefined scoring scheme and a strengths-weaknesses-opportunities-threats (SWOT)-like format for commenting. CONTENT: All three tools address multiple decision-making levels and aspects of stakeholder engagement. NEOH focuses on system features, learning, sharing, leadership and infrastructure, and requires a description of the underlying system in which AMR develops. AMR-PMP focuses on four areas: awareness, evidence, governance and practices and assesses the implementation degree of pre-chosen aspects within these areas. This requires less of the evaluator, but warrants participation of multiple stakeholders. SURVTOOL provides information and references on how to evaluate effectiveness, process and comprehensiveness of surveillance programmes. All three tools require veterinary epidemiology expertise and varying levels of evaluation methodology training to use appropriately. IMPLICATIONS: The tools covered AMR surveillance and One Health aspects to varying degrees. This study provides guidance on aspects to consider when choosing between available tools and embarking on an evaluation of integrated surveillance.
引用
- Nielsen LR, Alban L, Ellis-Iversen J, et al. Evaluating integrated surveillance of antimicrobial resistance: experiences from use of three evaluation tools. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2020. PMID: 32213319. doi:10.1016/j.cmi.2020.03.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。