氯己定醇与碘醇在择期关节置换术手术部位皮肤准备中的比较:ACAISA整群随机对照试验
ACAISA试验在择期髋或膝关节置换患者中比较0.5%氯己定葡萄糖酸盐/70%乙醇与1%碘/70%乙醇进行手术部位皮肤准备的效果。共纳入780例患者,每组390例。主要结局表浅伤口并发症无差异,但氯己定醇组手术部位感染和假体关节感染的几率均高于碘醇组。
要点
- 择期关节置换术中,氯己定醇与碘醇的表浅伤口并发症无差异。
- 氯己定醇组手术部位感染几率高于碘醇组(OR 3.06)。
- 氯己定醇组假体关节感染几率也高于碘醇组(OR 3.55)。
核心结论
- 主要结局表浅伤口并发症在氯己定醇与碘醇组间无差异。
- 次要分析显示碘醇在预防手术部位感染方面优于氯己定醇。
研究设计与样本
- 整群随机、对照、单中心、评估者盲法、优效性试验。
- 纳入择期髋或膝关节置换患者780例,氯己定醇组390例,碘醇组390例。
- 随机化单位为手术日,主要分析为意向性治疗,并考虑整群效应在术者层面分析。
主要发现
- 表浅伤口并发症:氯己定醇组19例(4.9%) vs 碘醇组15例(3.8%),OR 1.28(95%CI 0.62-2.63),p=0.50。
- 手术部位感染:氯己定醇组12例(3.1%) vs 碘醇组4例(1.0%),OR 3.06(95%CI 1.26-7.46),p=0.014。
- 假体关节感染:氯己定醇组7例(1.8%) vs 碘醇组2例(0.5%),OR 3.55(95%CI 1.20-10.44),p=0.022。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局为术后30天内表浅切口手术部位感染和/或临床显著伤口渗液的复合终点。
- 次要结局为任何手术部位感染,包括假体关节感染。
临床怎么用
- 择期髋或膝关节置换术皮肤准备可优先考虑碘醇而非氯己定醇。
- 需结合本地指南和患者个体情况综合决策。
局限性
- 单中心研究,外推性受限。
- 整群随机设计可能引入混杂。
- 次要结局事件数较少,估计不够精确。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Surgical site skin preparation is an effective method to prevent wound complications. The optimal agent has not been established, and guidelines contain conflicting recommendations. METHODS: The aim of alcoholic chlorhexidine or alcoholic iodine skin antisepsis (ACAISA) was to assess the efficacy of surgical site skin preparation with 0.5% chlorhexidine gluconate (w/v) in 70% ethanol (v/v) to 1% iodine (w/v) in 70% ethanol (v/v). This was a cluster randomized, controlled, single-centre, assessor-blinded, superiority trial in patients undergoing elective hip or knee arthroplasty. Each surgeon had a set operating day and the unit of randomization was the day of surgery. The primary outcome was superficial wound complication, defined as a composite endpoint of superficial incisional surgical site infection and/or clinically significant wound ooze in the 30 days following arthroplasty. The secondary outcome was any surgical site infection, including prosthetic joint infection. Outcome ascertainment was undertaken by an independent verification panel. The primary analysis was intention-to-treat, performed at the individual level. Taking into account the clustering effect, analysis of primary and secondary outcomes was undertaken at the level of the surgeon. RESULTS: A total of 780 participants were included; 390 participants were allocated chlorhexidine-alcohol and 390 participants were allocated iodine-alcohol. There was no difference in superficial wound complications: 19 (4.9%) versus 15 (3.8%) respectively (OR 1.28; 95%CI 0.62, 2.63; p 0.50). There was an increased odds of surgical site infection in the chlorhexidine-alcohol group compared to iodine-alcohol: 12 (3.1%) versus four (1.0%) respectively (OR 3.06; 95%CI 1.26, 7.46; p 0.014). The odds of prosthetic joint infection were also increased in the chlorhexidine-alcohol arm compared with iodine-alcohol: seven (1.8%) versus two (0.5%) respectively (OR 3.55; 95%CI 1.20, 10.44; p 0.022). CONCLUSIONS: No difference was observed in the primary outcome of superficial wound complications when chlorhexidine-alcohol and iodine-alcohol were compared. However, on a secondary analysis, iodine-alcohol had greater efficacy than chlorhexidine-alcohol for preventing surgical site infection. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry ACTRN12614000177651.
引用
- Peel TN, Dowsey MM, Buising KL, et al. Chlorhexidine-alcohol versus iodine-alcohol for surgical site skin preparation in an elective arthroplasty (ACAISA) study: a cluster randomized controlled trial. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2019. PMID: 31238121. doi:10.1016/j.cmi.2019.06.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。