坦桑尼亚发热门诊疟疾常规与超敏快速诊断试验的诊断性能
该研究在坦桑尼亚门诊回顾性比较超敏疟疾快速诊断试验(us-RDT)与常规RDT(co-RDT)在3000名儿童和515名发热成人中的诊断性能,以超敏qPCR为金标准。us-RDT仅比co-RDT多检出少量疟原虫阳性患者(276 vs 265),灵敏度略高(75% vs 73%),特异性均>99%。结论认为临床疟疾诊断中使用us-RDT相较co-RDT既无优势也无风险。
要点
- us-RDT与co-RDT灵敏度分别为75%和73%,特异性均>99%。
- 以us-qPCR为金标准,两者分别检出276和265例阳性。
- 仅小部分发热患者寄生虫密度或HRP2浓度处于us-RDT有优势的范围。
核心结论
- 临床疟疾诊断中使用us-RDT而非co-RDT既无优势也无风险。
- 发热患者中仅小部分感染的寄生虫密度或HRP2浓度处于us-RDT可带来有意义优势的范围。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性比较us-RDT与co-RDT诊断性能的研究。
- 纳入3000名儿童和515名发热成人,来自坦桑尼亚门诊。
- 以超敏qPCR检测寄生虫密度,以酶联免疫吸附试验检测HRP2浓度。
主要发现
- us-RDT检出276例疟原虫阳性患者,co-RDT检出265例。
- 以us-qPCR为金标准(检出357例阳性),us-RDT灵敏度75%,co-RDT灵敏度73%。
- 两种RDT特异性均>99%。
- us-RDT额外检出的11例阳性患者中5例us-qPCR阴性。
- 寄生虫密度>100个/µL时,99%(236/239)感染HRP2浓度超过co-RDT检测限(>3653 pg/mL)。
临床怎么用
- 在发热门诊中,us-RDT相较co-RDT未显示临床诊断优势,可继续使用常规RDT。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A novel ultrasensitive malaria rapid diagnostic test (us-RDT) has been developed for improved active Plasmodium falciparum infection detection. The usefulness of this us-RDT in clinical diagnosis and fever management has not been evaluated. METHODS: Diagnostic performance of us-RDT was compared retrospectively to that of conventional RDT (co-RDT) in 3000 children and 515 adults presenting with fever to Tanzanian outpatient clinics. The parasite density was measured by an ultrasensitive qPCR (us-qPCR), and the HRP2 concentration was measured by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. RESULTS: us-RDT identified few additional P. falciparum-positive patients as compared to co-RDT (276 vs 265 parasite-positive patients detected), with only a marginally greater sensitivity (75% vs 73%), using us-qPCR as the gold standard (357 parasite-positive patients detected). The specificity of both RDTs was >99%. Five of 11 additional patients testing positive by us-RDT had negative results by us-qPCR. The HRP2 concentration was above the limit of detection for co-RDT (>3653 pg of HRP2 per mL of blood) in almost all infections (99% [236 of 239]) with a parasite density >100 parasites per µL of blood. At parasite densities <100 parasites/µL, the HRP2 concentration was above the limits of detection of us-RDT (>793 pg/mL) and co-RDT in 29 (25%) and 24 (20%) of 118 patients, respectively. CONCLUSION: There is neither an advantage nor a risk of using us-RDT, rather than co-RDT, for clinical malaria diagnosis. In febrile patients, only a small proportion of infections are characterized by a parasite density or an HRP2 concentration in the range where use of us-RDT would confer a meaningful advantage over co-RDT.
引用
- Hofmann NE, Antunes Moniz C, Holzschuh A, et al. Diagnostic Performance of Conventional and Ultrasensitive Rapid Diagnostic Tests for Malaria in Febrile Outpatients in Tanzania. J Infect Dis. 2019. PMID: 30476111. doi:10.1093/infdis/jiy676
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。