简化WHO手卫生流程:整群随机试验比较三步法与六步法
在瑞士巴塞尔大学医院12个病区开展整群随机试验,比较含醇手揉搓三步法与WHO常规六步法的依从性和微生物学效果。三步法病区技术依从性51.7%、指征依从性75.9%,均高于六步法病区的12.7%和65.0%(P<.001)。两种方法细菌菌落减少因子无差异(P=.629),提示三步法可安全替代六步法。
要点
- 三步法技术依从性51.7%显著高于六步法12.7%,指征依从性亦更高
- 两种方法细菌减少因子无差异,三步法微生物学效果不劣于六步法
- 常规六步法可安全替换为更简单的三步手卫生技术
核心结论
- 在临床实践中,三步手卫生技术的指征依从性和技术依从性均高于六步法,且微生物学分析排除劣效性,常规六步法可被安全替代。
研究设计与样本
- 2015年10–11月在瑞士巴塞尔大学医院(三级学术医疗中心)开展整群随机试验,12个病区随机分配至三步法或六步法(ISRCTN45923734)。
主要发现
- 共观察2923次手卫生指征,总依从率70.7%(2066/2923)。
- 三步法病区技术依从性51.7%(595/1151)、指征依从性75.9%(1151/1516);六步法病区分别为12.7%(116/915)和65.0%(915/1407)(P<.001)。
- 细菌菌落减少因子中位数三步法0.97 log10 CFU(IQR 0.39–1.59),六步法1.04 log10 CFU(IQR 0.49–1.52),P=.629。
临床怎么用
- 在常规临床病区可推广三步含醇手揉搓法,以提高手卫生指征与技术依从性,且不牺牲微生物学效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In an experimental setting, a simplified, 3-step hand hygiene technique for applying alcohol-based hand rub was non inferior in terms of reduction of bacterial counts, as compared to the conventional World Health Organization 6-step technique. We therefore compared compliance and microbiological efficacy between both hand hygiene techniques in routine clinical practice. METHODS: We performed a cluster-randomized trial from October-November 2015 at the University Hospital Basel, Switzerland: a tertiary, academic care center (ISRCTN45923734). We randomly assigned 12 wards to either the 3-step technique or the conventional 6-step technique of hand rubbing. The primary endpoints were compliance with the assigned technique and reduction of bacterial counts on the hands of health-care workers. RESULTS: Overall, 2923 hand hygiene indications were observed, and compliance was 70.7% (2066/2923). Compliance with technique and indications was 51.7% (595/1151) and 75.9% (1151/1516) on wards assigned to the 3-step technique, respectively, as compared to 12.7% (116/915) and 65.0% (915/1407) on wards assigned to the 6-step technique (P < .001). The reduction factor (RF) of bacterial colony counts did not differ between techniques (median RF 0.97 log10 colony-forming units [CFU] [interquartile range 0.39-1.59] for the 3-step technique vs median RF 1.04 log10 CFU [interquartile range 0.49-1.52] for the 6-step technique; P = .629). CONCLUSIONS: In a clinical setting, the simpler hand hygiene technique, consisting of 3 steps, resulted in higher compliance with both hand hygiene indications and technique, as compared to the 6 steps. As the results of the microbiological analyses exclude inferiority, the conventional 6 steps could be safely replaced by a simpler hand hygiene technique. CLINICAL TRIALS REGISTRATION: ISRCTN45923734.
引用
- Tschudin-Sutter S, Sepulcri D, Dangel M, et al. Simplifying the World Health Organization Protocol: 3 Steps Versus 6 Steps for Performance of Hand Hygiene in a Cluster-randomized Trial. Clin Infect Dis. 2019. PMID: 30395180. doi:10.1093/cid/ciy948
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。