梅毒螺旋体试验诊断梅毒的性能评价
该研究以临床诊断联合血清学结果为参考标准,比较7种梅毒螺旋体试验在959例参与者中的敏感性和特异性。FTA-ABS对一期梅毒敏感性(78.2%)低于免疫分析法和TPPA(94.5%-96.4%),TPPA特异性达100%。作者认为TPPA因高特异性与优越敏感性,在反向序列算法中优于FTA-ABS用于裁决不一致结果。
要点
- FTA-ABS对一期梅毒敏感性78.2%,低于免疫分析法和TPPA的94.5%-96.4%(均P≤.01)。
- 所有免疫分析法对二期梅毒敏感性100%,早期潜伏95.2%-100%,晚期潜伏86.8%-98.5%。
- TPPA特异性100%,作者认为在反向序列算法中优于FTA-ABS用于裁决不一致结果。
核心结论
- 梅毒螺旋体免疫分析法对二期、早期潜伏及血清阳性一期梅毒显示极佳敏感性,FTA-ABS对一期梅毒敏感性差。
- 鉴于TPPA高特异性和优越敏感性,作者认为在反向序列算法中TPPA优于FTA-ABS用于裁决不一致结果。
研究设计与样本
- 计算7种梅毒螺旋体试验的敏感性和特异性,以临床诊断联合血清学结果为参考标准。
- 血清采集于2012年5月至2013年1月,共959例参与者:262例当前梅毒、294例既往梅毒、403例无梅毒。
主要发现
- FTA-ABS对一期梅毒敏感性78.2%,低于免疫分析法和TPPA的94.5%-96.4%(均P≤.01)。
- 所有免疫分析法对二期梅毒敏感性100%,早期潜伏95.2%-100%,晚期潜伏86.8%-98.5%。
- TPPA特异性100%。
关键数值与推荐
- FTA-ABS对一期梅毒敏感性78.2%,免疫分析法和TPPA为94.5%-96.4%(均P≤.01)。
- 免疫分析法对二期梅毒敏感性100%,早期潜伏95.2%-100%,晚期潜伏86.8%-98.5%。
- TPPA特异性100%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,鉴于TPPA高特异性和优越敏感性,在反向序列算法中TPPA优于FTA-ABS用于裁决不一致结果。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Treponemal immunoassays are increasingly used for syphilis screening with the reverse sequence algorithm. There are few data describing performance of treponemal immunoassays compared to traditional treponemal tests in patients with and without syphilis. METHODS: We calculated sensitivity and specificity of 7 treponemal assays: (1) ADVIA Centaur (chemiluminescence immunoassay [CIA]); (2) Bioplex 2200 (microbead immunoassay); (3) fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption test (FTA-ABS); (4) INNO-LIA (line immunoassay); (5) LIAISON CIA; (6) Treponema pallidum particle agglutination assay (TPPA); and (7) Trep-Sure (enzyme immunoassay [EIA]), using a reference standard combining clinical diagnosis and serology results. Sera were collected between May 2012-January 2013. Cases were characterized as: (1) current clinical diagnosis of syphilis: primary, secondary, early latent, late latent; (2) prior treated syphilis only; (3) no evidence of current syphilis, no prior history of syphilis, and at least 4 of 7 treponemal tests negative. RESULTS: Among 959 participants, 262 had current syphilis, 294 had prior syphilis, and 403 did not have syphilis. FTA-ABS was less sensitive for primary syphilis (78.2%) than the immunoassays or TPPA (94.5%-96.4%) (all P ≤ .01). All immunoassays were 100% sensitive for secondary syphilis, 95.2%-100% sensitive for early latent disease, and 86.8%-98.5% sensitive in late latent disease. TPPA had 100% specificity. CONCLUSIONS: Treponemal immunoassays demonstrated excellent sensitivity for secondary, early latent, and seropositive primary syphilis. Sensitivity of FTA-ABS in primary syphilis was poor. Given its high specificity and superior sensitivity, TPPA is preferred to adjudicate discordant results with the reverse sequence algorithm over the FTA-ABS.
引用
- Park IU, Fakile YF, Chow JM, et al. Performance of Treponemal Tests for the Diagnosis of Syphilis. Clin Infect Dis. 2019. PMID: 29986091. doi:10.1093/cid/ciy558
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。