抗生素管理:医院实践是否有效?证据基础综述
该综述基于已发表的系统评价与Medline文献,总结医院实践中合理抗生素使用推荐(「做什么」)与行为改变干预(「怎么做」)的证据基础。文献显示合理抗生素使用对住院患者的正面效应证据质量低,任何行为改变干预都可能有效但研究间改善差异大。作者指出需采用随机对照设计验证合理抗生素使用对有意义结局的效果,并应从行为科学中学习选择干预措施。
要点
- 合理抗生素使用对住院患者的正面效应证据质量低,需随机对照设计验证。
- 任何行为改变干预都可能有效,但类似干预在不同研究间改善差异大。
- 抗生素管理团队应基于障碍与促进因素的评估及理论选择行为改变干预。
核心结论
- 文献显示合理抗生素使用对住院患者的正面效应证据质量低。
- 任何行为改变干预都可能有效,但类似干预在不同研究间改善差异大。
- 需采用随机对照设计验证合理抗生素使用对有意义结局的效果。
研究设计与样本
- 综述基于已发表的系统评价与Medline文献。
主要发现
- 合理抗生素使用对住院患者的正面效应证据质量低。
- 任何行为改变干预都可能有效,但类似干预在不同研究间改善差异大。
临床怎么用
- 抗生素管理团队应基于障碍与促进因素的仔细评估及理论选择行为改变干预。
- 选择干预措施时应从行为科学中学习。
局限性
- 大多数当前研究使用的设计易受指征混杂影响。
- 未来研究应应用更稳健的设计与评估来评价行为改变干预。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Guidelines for developing and implementing stewardship programmes include recommendations on appropriate antibiotic use to guide the stewardship team's choice of potential stewardship objectives. They also include recommendations on behavioural change interventions to guide the team's choice of potential interventions to ensure that professionals actually use antibiotics appropriately in daily practice. AIMS: To summarize the evidence base of both appropriate antibiotic use recommendations (the 'what') and behavioural change interventions (the 'how') in hospital practice. SOURCES: Published systematic reviews/Medline. CONTENT: The literature shows low-quality evidence of the positive effects of appropriate antibiotic use in hospital patients. The literature shows that any behavioural change intervention might work to ensure that professionals actually perform appropriate antibiotic use recommendations in daily practice. Although effects were overall positive, there were large differences in improvement between studies that tested similar change interventions. IMPLICATIONS: The literature showed a clear need for studies that apply appropriate study designs- (randomized) controlled designs-to test the effectiveness of appropriate antibiotic use on achieving meaningful outcomes. Most current studies used designs prone to confounding by indication. In the process of selecting behavioural change interventions that might work best in a chosen setting, much should be learned from behavioural sciences. The challenge for stewardship teams lies in selecting change interventions on the careful assessment of barriers and facilitators, and on a theoretical base while linking determinants to change interventions. Future studies should apply more robust designs and evaluations when assessing behavioural change interventions.
引用
- Hulscher MEJL, Prins JM. Antibiotic stewardship: does it work in hospital practice? A review of the evidence base. Clin Microbiol Infect. 2017. PMID: 28750920. doi:10.1016/j.cmi.2017.07.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。